PHILADELPHIA | Highrise Development Thread X


I don't feel great, is Philly the biggest NIMBY city in the entire country? I have to imagine the insane amount of opposition so many developments face has an impact on whether larger projects are even considered.
Even though it's vastly ahead of Philly in every economic metric, I am aware Boston has serious NIMBY problems. I don't know what other cities have that problem.

Amsterdam is the largest city in Holland, a major air and rail hub for Holland thanks to one of the busiest airports in the world (Schipol), and one of the busiest rail stations in Europe, the economic, commercial, and cultural center of Holland, the most visited city in Holland, and one of the most visited cities in the world.

I know a lot do not like to use the GaWC chart when comparing cities, but as of 2022, Amsterdam is still ranked as an Alpha city, while Philadelphia is now a Beta- city, now below cities such as Denver and Seattle, which are currently Beta cities (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Globalization_and_World_Cities_Research_Network#Alpha).

I wonder what it would take to make Philadelphia a truly global city. We have several things going against us. We're wedged between NYC and DC and Boston's not too far. Our universities can't retain their business students. The airport has extremely limited international options. I'm hoping that 2026 can put a larger spotlight on the city; although everyone has to be on their best behavior.
 
Even though it's vastly ahead of Philly in every economic metric, I am aware Boston has serious NIMBY problems. I don't know what other cities have that problem.



I wonder what it would take to make Philadelphia a truly global city. We have several things going against us. We're wedged between NYC and DC and Boston's not too far. Our universities can't retain their business students. The airport has extremely limited international options. I'm hoping that 2026 can put a larger spotlight on the city; although everyone has to be on their best behavior.

Making Philly desirable economically would go a long way towards fixing all of those things.
 
Comments like this make me think you're either 21 and don't have experience with this stuff and/or you've never lived anywhere else.

This seems a little unnecessary to say, & I've lived in a few other major cities but they were quite different than Philly.

To your other points, Squilla's district is an obvious exception.
 
Even though it's vastly ahead of Philly in every economic metric, I am aware Boston has serious NIMBY problems. I don't know what other cities have that problem.



I wonder what it would take to make Philadelphia a truly global city. We have several things going against us. We're wedged between NYC and DC and Boston's not too far. Our universities can't retain their business students. The airport has extremely limited international options. I'm hoping that 2026 can put a larger spotlight on the city; although everyone has to be on their best behavior.

I think calling the international options 'extremely limited' is a bit harsh. Yes, it's primarily one carrier but the destinations hit nearly every major city in Europe. There are not many other airports that serve smaller cities like Nice, Copenhagen, Venice, Naples direct. Plus they service nearly every stop in the Caribbean. We'd all like more carriers for better prices and direct flights to Asia but I think the options here are not bad.

As for other Metros in the south; I believe their growth is nearing their apex. Cost of living was a major factor but that has gone out the window. Yes they have a much friendlier business climate (which will remain a tailwind). Climate change is a big deal, I have friends in Austin who complain it's unlivable during the summer. I think these younger generations are going to head north, sort of anti-boomer-to-the-sunbelt type migration. Affordable cities in temperate climates like Detroit, MSP, etc will stand to gain.

Just my two cents.
 
The difference between Philly and Amsterdam is that Philly is the sixth largest major city in the US, a major legacy city, the original US capital before it moved to DC, and the site of the Declaration of Independence, the Bill of Rights, and the US Constitution. It's a city that's tied to it's colonial past, for better or worse.

Amsterdam is the largest city in Holland, a major air and rail hub for Holland thanks to one of the busiest airports in the world (Schipol), and one of the busiest rail stations in Europe, the economic, commercial, and cultural center of Holland, the most visited city in Holland, and one of the most visited cities in the world.

I know a lot do not like to use the GaWC chart when comparing cities, but as of 2022, Amsterdam is still ranked as an Alpha city, while Philadelphia is now a Beta- city, now below cities such as Denver and Seattle, which are currently Beta cities (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Globalization_and_World_Cities_Research_Network#Alpha).

What's the equivalent of the De Wallen district in Amsterdam, the center for cannabis and legalized prostitution? The closest I can think of is Old City, and there's no cannabis dispensaries nor any legalized prostitution anywhere (both are illegal in PA).

Also, Amsterdam is known as the "Venice of the North" due to the numerous canals that traverse throughout the city's center. We don't have canals anywhere in Philly. The closest city to Amsterdam in the US is New York, since it's old name used to be Amsterdam, and the Dutch colonists used to inhabit New Amsterdam until it became New York thanks to the Brits. Also, Dutch names such as Wyckoff, Vandeveer, and Bushwick are either street names or place names in NY. The Roosevelts (Teddy and FDR) are descended from the Dutch, as is Van Buren. Finally, the flag of NYC is based of the Dutch's original colors of blue, white, and orange, and the seal of NYC contains a windmill, a symbol of the Dutch. The city flag of Philly is light blue and gold, the colors of Sweden.

If there was a European city or cities that I can think of that's closest to Philly, it's London (for the British colonists), Paris (for the museums along the Parkway, which was modeled after the Champs Elysees), and maybe a sprinkling of Rome (due to the Sports Complex and the Italians that live in South Philly).

There is no neighborhood in the US, let alone Philly, that can compare to what I saw in De Wallen lol.

I want Philly to be like Amsterdam in terms of the urban experience. Amsterdam, especially the historic center, is full of mixed-use rowhome neighborhoods reminiscent of ours. Everything is tied together by streetcar lines, some heavy rail, very frequent NS trains, and tons of bike lanes. There are also no disheveled neighborhoods anywhere in the city, as each neighborhood is given money to promote neighborhood upkeep. Had Philly maintained its housing stock, trolley lines, and commercial districts, and if SEPTA ran the Regional Rail more like a metro, Philly and Amsterdam could have a somewhat analogous urban form minus the canal system.

I agree that London is a close analogue to Philly, but significantly larger in scale. The tight streets, rowhomes, lively pubs, and distinct neighborhoods made me feel at home. Camden Town (possibly my favorite neighborhood in London) in particular felt like a mix of what South Street used to be and what Fishtown currently is. If I didn't love Philly so much and weren't so financially invested, I'd strongly consider emigrating to the UK.
 
I think calling the international options 'extremely limited' is a bit harsh. Yes, it's primarily one carrier but the destinations hit nearly every major city in Europe. There are not many other airports that serve smaller cities like Nice, Copenhagen, Venice, Naples direct. Plus they service nearly every stop in the Caribbean. We'd all like more carriers for better prices and direct flights to Asia but I think the options here are not bad.

As for other Metros in the south; I believe their growth is nearing their apex. Cost of living was a major factor but that has gone out the window. Yes they have a much friendlier business climate (which will remain a tailwind). Climate change is a big deal, I have friends in Austin who complain it's unlivable during the summer. I think these younger generations are going to head north, sort of anti-boomer-to-the-sunbelt type migration. Affordable cities in temperate climates like Detroit, MSP, etc will stand to gain.

Just my two cents.
Detroit can't gain because it lacks any semblance of public transit. The Q Line doesn't do much besides ferry people back and forth from downtown to the Pistons stadium and Amshack.

I agree with the rest of your analysis, though. Cities like Boston, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, and yes, Philadelphia will stand to benefit quite a bit from the phenomenon you're talking about. Pittsburgh and St. Louis (and maybe Cleveland) have some rail transit and can support an influx of residents to an extent, and are rather affordable at the moment. Pittsburgh has a rather large tech industry blossoming, and Saint Louis now has several higher-speed trains a day to Chicago.
 
I wonder what it would take to make Philadelphia a truly global city. We have several things going against us. We're wedged between NYC and DC and Boston's not too far. Our universities can't retain their business students. The airport has extremely limited international options. I'm hoping that 2026 can put a larger spotlight on the city; although everyone has to be on their best behavior.


Making Philly desirable economically would go a long way towards fixing all of those things.

^ This.
Not counting the suburbs, there aren't enough career opportunities in Philadelphia proper. And being sandwiched between NYC and DC is a forever knock on Philadelphia's national and global reach.

The city needs to continue to capitalize on this...
Philadelphia region moves up in JLL ranking of the country's top life sciences clusters
https://www.bizjournals.com/philade...ces-cluster-philadelphia-ranking-jll-bio.html

Life sciences, startups, tech, and becoming a more lucrative place for major law firms, finance firms, engineering firms, etc., to open satellites, will help the city grow in the ranks and increase student retention rates. (I think 3 Am Law 100 firms opened Philadelphia offices recently?) And of course improving the QOL, lowering crime, poverty, etc., is all a given.

As far as the airport, it's decently competitive (definitely not "extremely limited"), but at some point, PHL needs to follow EWR and LGA and start replacing the oldest terminals.

And maybe a hot take, but a Michelin Red Guide would boost Philadelphia's international profile (yes, its pay-to-play and pretentious, but still a thing, and Philadelphia is an incredible food city).

*Edit, between Shapiro and Parker, Philadelphia is in a good position to accomplish some of these things in the next 4-8 years. They see the bigger picture for the city and commonwealth.
 
Last edited:
Detroit can't gain because it lacks any semblance of public transit. The Q Line doesn't do much besides ferry people back and forth from downtown to the Pistons stadium and Amshack.

I agree with the rest of your analysis, though. Cities like Boston, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, and yes, Philadelphia will stand to benefit quite a bit from the phenomenon you're talking about. Pittsburgh and St. Louis (and maybe Cleveland) have some rail transit and can support an influx of residents to an extent, and are rather affordable at the moment. Pittsburgh has a rather large tech industry blossoming, and Saint Louis now has several higher-speed trains a day to Chicago.

We (people) have been saying this about Pittsburgh for 30 years, and while underrated and an amazing cultural city for its size with elite universities/research, continues to lose residents at a faster rate that all major cities (save NOLA).

Climate change refugees is a bit overblown (at least in the wealthy US, where we can adapt with technology), especially now that "climate change haven" Asheville has been effectively destroyed by a clear result of climate change. A/C goes a long way to allowing the south to remain livable. People flat out don't like cold weather way more than they don't like hot, generally speaking. I can't mention I'm originally from Buffalo without utter shock on people's face for "how can a human live there, it's much too cold".

For all these global rankings people need to realize how much is about perception more than anything else. These rankings have litte to do with real metrics (like US News college rankings. Mostly bogus). I had Portland friends travel to NYC last year, took the train to DC for tourism reasons, bypassing Philly. They get back and say how mad they are they didn't stay in Philly after seeing the skyline on the train into 30th Street, they had "no idea Philly was so big and urban". People simply don't understand and have a very poor grasp of what Philly is. People don't understand much beyond what is popular.

Having a lower perception doesn't make Philly less off, but it does make it way more affordable for those that understand how amazing Center City is. There is no better (real) urban value than Center City Philly, by a long shot.
 
We (people) have been saying this about Pittsburgh for 30 years, and while underrated and an amazing cultural city for its size with elite universities/research, continues to lose residents at a faster rate that all major cities (save NOLA).

Climate change refugees is a bit overblown (at least in the wealthy US, where we can adapt with technology), especially now that "climate change haven" Asheville has been effectively destroyed by a clear result of climate change. A/C goes a long way to allowing the south to remain livable. People flat out don't like cold weather way more than they don't like hot, generally speaking. I can't mention I'm originally from Buffalo without utter shock on people's face for "how can a human live there, it's much too cold".

For all these global rankings people need to realize how much is about perception more than anything else. These rankings have litte to do with real metrics (like US News college rankings. Mostly bogus). I had Portland friends travel to NYC last year, took the train to DC for tourism reasons, bypassing Philly. They get back and say how mad they are they didn't stay in Philly after seeing the skyline on the train into 30th Street, they had "no idea Philly was so big and urban". People simply don't understand and have a very poor grasp of what Philly is. People don't understand much beyond what is popular.

Having a lower perception doesn't make Philly less off, but it does make it way more affordable for those that understand how amazing Center City is. There is no better (real) urban value than Center City Philly, by a long shot.

Philly is bad at marketing itself to the outside world (and maybe most want it that way), but it's also why none of my friends are visiting philly for a weekend, or would consider to move, they don't know about it! You have to seek out or stumble upon philly if you have no connection to it, but that is part of the charm I suppose. Whenever I post photos of philly, I always get asked where is that, or that's in philly??
 
Philly is bad at marketing itself to the outside world (and maybe most want it that way), but it's also why none of my friends are visiting philly for a weekend, or would consider to move, they don't know about it! You have to seek out or stumble upon philly if you have no connection to it, but that is part of the charm I suppose. Whenever I post photos of philly, I always get asked where is that, or that's in philly??

Yup. Friends from nyc used to visit, “holy cow this city so nice and clean”. Amazed them (areas in CCD, to be sure).
 
We (people) have been saying this about Pittsburgh for 30 years, and while underrated and an amazing cultural city for its size with elite universities/research, continues to lose residents at a faster rate that all major cities (save NOLA).
.

Pittsburgh is a very lovely place but has some of the worst weather in the US. I believe it's on par with the PNW for number of cloudy days per year. It's quite depressing.
My wife has to stay downtown PGH for work once a month and she always comments how sketchy downtown is compared to here (we live in CC). It's too bad. We are fortunate to have such a populated CBD to keep the streets active.

Philly has been an underrated gem for a long time but I think the word is getting out. Nearly every post on reddit/sameGrassButGreener has Philly mentioned. Sure not everyone can deal with the cold but these younger generations aren't used to the temperate summers we grew up with. Time will tell.
 
I think calling the international options 'extremely limited' is a bit harsh. Yes, it's primarily one carrier but the destinations hit nearly every major city in Europe. There are not many other airports that serve smaller cities like Nice, Copenhagen, Venice, Naples direct. Plus they service nearly every stop in the Caribbean. We'd all like more carriers for better prices and direct flights to Asia but I think the options here are not bad.

I get your point, but I stand by this. Compared to the other cities that have the same economic and population numbers we do, every major city in Europe is the bare minimum. Frankfurt is only 5 days a week on a budget lesiure carrier. Plus, not only do we not have any direct flights to Asia, we don't have any to Central or South America either. We're barely connected to the world outside of a selection in Europe and leisure destinations in the Caribbean.

Copenhagen, Naples, and Nice are fine, but they're not really for Philly, if that makes sense. If they could fly those out of JFK or Boston, they would do it in a heartbeat. That's actually my big fear with the airport; is that JetBlue goes under and then AA abandons Philly for New York and/or Boston and we're left with nothing. There is very much a reality where that happens.

Coming in dead last on the entire continent on this year's JD Power certainly doesn't help either.
 
I get your point, but I stand by this. Compared to the other cities that have the same economic and population numbers we do, every major city in Europe is the bare minimum. Frankfurt is only 5 days a week on a budget lesiure carrier. Plus, not only do we not have any direct flights to Asia, we don't have any to Central or South America either. We're barely connected to the world outside of a selection in Europe and leisure destinations in the Caribbean.

Copenhagen, Naples, and Nice are fine, but they're not really for Philly, if that makes sense. If they could fly those out of JFK or Boston, they would do it in a heartbeat. That's actually my big fear with the airport; is that JetBlue goes under and then AA abandons Philly for New York and/or Boston and we're left with nothing. There is very much a reality where that happens.

Coming in dead last on the entire continent on this year's JD Power certainly doesn't help either.

I get your gripes, and PHL will never be EWR, JFK, IAD, etc., but has room to improve and become more competitive. I still vote for knocking down terminals and building new instead of piecemeal repairs.

However, to the bold, most major airports act as connectors and are not for the people in those cities. See Atlanta, Charlotte, Dallas, etc. Plus, Philadelphia being a connection hub for Europe is a good thing, and JFK cannot handle the additional traffic, so I don't see that changing.

Also, EWR came in last for mega airports and EWR ranks 4th in US for most global connections. Yes, Philadelphia needs to do better, but a JD Power ranking is not a deterrent for international traffic.
 
Last edited:
I get your point, but I stand by this. Compared to the other cities that have the same economic and population numbers we do, every major city in Europe is the bare minimum. Frankfurt is only 5 days a week on a budget lesiure carrier. Plus, not only do we not have any direct flights to Asia, we don't have any to Central or South America either. We're barely connected to the world outside of a selection in Europe and leisure destinations in the Caribbean.

Copenhagen, Naples, and Nice are fine, but they're not really for Philly, if that makes sense. If they could fly those out of JFK or Boston, they would do it in a heartbeat. That's actually my big fear with the airport; is that JetBlue goes under and then AA abandons Philly for New York and/or Boston and we're left with nothing. There is very much a reality where that happens.

Coming in dead last on the entire continent on this year's JD Power certainly doesn't help either.

I doubt that AA would ditch PHL for JFK or especially BOS. BOS is an entrenched Delta/JetBlue hub that AA would really have to fight for to gain market share. JFK is a great airport for origin and destination (O&D) traffic, but it has a litany of problems that would prevent it from being a hub for connecting traffic--most notably, it's congested airspace and slot-restricted nature. PHL offers AA a level of flexibility that JFK can't.

If anything, I bet AA would love to consolidate its operations out of Charlotte. I do agree that AA traditionally hasn't put as much thought into PHL, but I do believe that's changing. The clearest sign of this is the fact that AA is building out a Flagship Lounge in Terminal A West. I also believe that we'll see more international destinations in the coming years. AA is waiting on Boeing to deliver the 25 787-9 Dreamliners from its order book. AA has a shortage of widebody aircraft after it decided to retire its Airbus A330 fleet at the onset of the pandemic.
 
I doubt that AA would ditch PHL for JFK or especially BOS. BOS is an entrenched Delta/JetBlue hub that AA would really have to fight for to gain market share. JFK is a great airport for origin and destination (O&D) traffic, but it has a litany of problems that would prevent it from being a hub for connecting traffic--most notably, it's congested airspace and slot-restricted nature. PHL offers AA a level of flexibility that JFK can't.

If anything, I bet AA would love to consolidate its operations out of Charlotte. I do agree that AA traditionally hasn't put as much thought into PHL, but I do believe that's changing. The clearest sign of this is the fact that AA is building out a Flagship Lounge in Terminal A West. I also believe that we'll see more international destinations in the coming years. AA is waiting on Boeing to deliver the 25 787-9 Dreamliners from its order book. AA has a shortage of widebody aircraft after it decided to retire its Airbus A330 fleet at the onset of the pandemic.

I agree. PHL isn't going anywhere. The entire airspace around NYC is already constrained. If anything, PHL will benefit from that.

On top of it, we're still at the center of a region with 6+ million people. We're not going to ever be in a position to not have a major international airport with organic traffic alone. On top of that, the changing demography of the region at some point (I would think) would make China and India flights non-negotiable. I think people from this region are absolutely okay to go to Newark for an international flight. JFK is a much harder sell. It is just much more remote and harder to get to when originating in this area.
 
I agree. PHL isn't going anywhere. The entire airspace around NYC is already constrained. If anything, PHL will benefit from that.

On top of it, we're still at the center of a region with 6+ million people. We're not going to ever be in a position to not have a major international airport with organic traffic alone. On top of that, the changing demography of the region at some point (I would think) would make China and India flights non-negotiable. I think people from this region are absolutely okay to go to Newark for an international flight. JFK is a much harder sell. It is just much more remote and harder to get to when originating in this area.

The only time I flew JFK was flying EVA air to Taipei, because they offer a free shuttle service to and from the Asian market at 6th and Washington, which is within walking distance to me. They also offer it from Chelenham and probably other places.

Other than that, I'd pay more to avoid JFK.
 
I wonder what it would take to make Philadelphia a truly global city. We have several things going against us. We're wedged between NYC and DC and Boston's not too far. Our universities can't retain their business students. The airport has extremely limited international options. I'm hoping that 2026 can put a larger spotlight on the city; although everyone has to be on their best behavior.

I'm pretty convinced that Philly is basically a legacy city, along with Cleveland, Detroit, and St. Louis. Only difference is that those cities either have never reached 1 million or, in the case of Detroit, was over 1 million people between 1920 to 1990, then fell below 1 million back in 2000, and has never seen that threshold again.

Also, Detroit, around the 50's to the 60's, was the richest city in America, the way SF is the richest city today. And, for it's heyday, Detroit was considered a world class city during that time until the 90's. Philly had a world class cache because it was a Top 5 city for so long since colonial times until 2014, when Phoenix passed it by, and had a lot of HQs here such as Sunoco, Arco, Rohm and Haas, Sovereign, UGI, and Crown Cork and Seal. Many of those companies have either moved to the suburbs, or moved to different cities (Sunoco moved to Dallas, and Sovereign became Santander Bank and moved to Boston).

It doesn't help that Philly don't have an extensive mass transit system, the airport doesn't have int'l air carriers like KLM, Copa, and JAL, and the city has the highest wage and business taxes in the nation. Only mayor I can recall that tried to promote Philly was Rendell. After Rendell, we've had subpar mayors as far as mayors who promoted Philly to tourists and businesses alike.
 
There is no neighborhood in the US, let alone Philly, that can compare to what I saw in De Wallen lol.

I want Philly to be like Amsterdam in terms of the urban experience. Amsterdam, especially the historic center, is full of mixed-use rowhome neighborhoods reminiscent of ours. Everything is tied together by streetcar lines, some heavy rail, very frequent NS trains, and tons of bike lanes. There are also no disheveled neighborhoods anywhere in the city, as each neighborhood is given money to promote neighborhood upkeep. Had Philly maintained its housing stock, trolley lines, and commercial districts, and if SEPTA ran the Regional Rail more like a metro, Philly and Amsterdam could have a somewhat analogous urban form minus the canal system.

I agree that London is a close analogue to Philly, but significantly larger in scale. The tight streets, rowhomes, lively pubs, and distinct neighborhoods made me feel at home. Camden Town (possibly my favorite neighborhood in London) in particular felt like a mix of what South Street used to be and what Fishtown currently is. If I didn't love Philly so much and weren't so financially invested, I'd strongly consider emigrating to the UK.

Amsterdam is in Europe, where mass transit is at a premium, which is why every European capital from London to Paris, Madrid to Rome, and even Warsaw and Stockholm has better mass transit options that your typical American city. Some regional rail routes (the Norristown, Fox Chase, and Chestnut Hill Lines) should've been converted to the city's subway system long time ago. The lack of insight and foresight is why Philly isn't the world class city in comparison to Boston, Miami, DC, and SF, because of the political leadership in the city and the state.
 
I'm pretty convinced that Philly is basically a legacy city, along with Cleveland, Detroit, and St. Louis.

Good Lord.

Are Cleveland, Detroit, and St. Louis in the Top 10 metros for economic output, Top 5 metros for raw volumes of job growth, Top 5 metros for venture capital dollars, Top 10 metros for talent attraction, and one of the key lynchpins for the absolute wealthiest and most economically productive urban agglomeration on Earth, also known as the Northeast Corridor?

This narrative is so counter-productive and ridiculous in 2024. Yes, Philly has so much more to gain and improve upon, but to suggest that its current baseline is even remotely close to any of the actual legacy cities you've pointed to as analogues, is completely devoid of logic and divorced from reality.
 
Good Lord.

Are Cleveland, Detroit, and St. Louis in the Top 10 metros for economic output, Top 5 metros for raw volumes of job growth, Top 5 metros for venture capital dollars, Top 10 metros for talent attraction, and one of the key lynchpins for the absolute wealthiest and most economically productive urban agglomeration on Earth, also known as the Northeast Corridor?

This narrative is so counter-productive and ridiculous in 2024. Yes, Philly has so much more to gain and improve upon, but to suggest that its current baseline is even remotely close to any of the legacy cities you've pointed to as analogues, is completely devoid of logic and divorced from reality.

I think people get too focused on Census defined metro areas and that misses the (unique to the USA) grey area that is the overall Philly-NYC combined area. The fact Trenton/Princeton area are officially in NYC metro and not Philly shows the fine line between the two. So all the big pharma in that area is considered part of NYC, but is it really? Trenton practically touches Northeast Philly. I had many friends that lived in Philly work in that area, because why not? It's so close. But then you look at GDP, etc, and it appears distinctly separate. It's clearly not.
 


Back
Top