OrdoSeclorum
Member
I hope the DNC goes well next week. Saw a bunch of helicopters flying low around my area this morning.
At least of those are "nuke sniffers" that have passive radiation detection equipment on board.
I hope the DNC goes well next week. Saw a bunch of helicopters flying low around my area this morning.
Kudos to our city's police department for keeping control of the potentially volatile DNC protests, and preserving order.
Despite all of the fear-mongering that this was gonna be '68 all over again, it didn't come to pass, thank God!
Black eye for the city successfully avoided.
Thank you, Larry Snelling.
The fact that Johnson refused to renew ShotSpotter’s contract is quite disappointing, and I wish people would discuss it more because it’s such a vital tool.
In May 2021, the MacArthur Justice Center released a study that found most ShotSpotter alerts turn up no evidence of gunfire or any gun-related crime but instead send police on thousands of unfounded and high-intensity deployments, which are focused almost exclusively in Black and Brown communities. The researchers found that 89% of ShotSpotter deployments in Chicago turned up no gun-related crime and 86% led to no report of any crime at all.
One study published in April in the peer-reviewed Journal of Urban Health examined ShotSpotter in 68 large, metropolitan counties from 1999 to 2016, the largest review to date. It found that the technology didn’t reduce gun violence or increase community safety.
“The evidence that we’ve produced suggests that the technology does not reduce firearm violence in the long-term, and the implementation of the technology does not lead to increased murder or weapons-related arrests,” said lead author Mitch Doucette.
Another study published in November, by Michael Topper and Toshio Ferrazares, PhD students at the University of California, Santa Barbara, looking at Chicago, found that after the roll-out of Shotspotter the police responded to 9/11 calls two minutes slower than before, and in the case of domestic-violence calls made fewer arrests. Ralph Clark, the CEO of SoundThinking, says people who think the tool is directly able to prevent violent crime are “singularly misinformed”.
the MacArthur Justice Center
I think Shotspotter is far over-selling what its sensors can do. Acoustic propagation unfortunately is quite complicated, and I think they're partially in the business of providing "evidence" to police when convenient. It's too bad because if the technology actually worked well it would be helpful.
I don't see any reason why a Shotspotter technology couldn't work and be helpful, even if the current implementation doesn't work today. I'd be curious if the issue is differentiating fireworks vs gunshot, but I assume that's where analysis of the soundwave should be far more accurate than the human ear. And similar to satellite geolocation, if there are enough Shotspotter mics then they should be able to triangulate and pinpoint where the shots are coming from. This would be far better than relying on 911 calls; every couple months in the summer we wake up to a series of gunshots at 4am but feel helpless because the shots could be coming from any direction. Quarter mile radius? half mile radius? no fucking clue. Hoping that 911 uses the location of various reports to identify a general region where the shots may have come from, which is why we bother to call it in, but it seems doubtful they do anything even that sophisticated.
The Shotspotter tech works quite well honestly. I’ve seen it personally in action on the streets three separate times for shooting incidents. I’ve never seen a response for fireworks.
The issue is that criminals firing into the air or in alleys, or doing drive bys against property for fun with no witnesses or victims around are extremely common.
The missing ballistic evidence turns up a year later lodged in someone’s garage half a mile away long after the police report had been filed for “no evidence found.”
911 calls are 100 times more useless because no human can pinpoint the exact location of shots fired.
It’s not so much that Shotspotter reduces crime by itself, so much as it saves lives by locating victims who are bleeding out in an alley unnoticed by witnesses.
I think Ordo makes a good point though...... Even if it's just people firing guns into the air and there are no victims - That in itself is useful information.
If we know where shots are being fired the most around the city - That makes it easier to allocate police resources to the said areas.
Why you would want to throw the baby with the bathwater out is beyond me......
A family party with fireworks is where you don't want armed police showing up. Shotspotter makes that less likely to happen. And if there is gunfire and you don't want police responding as rapidly as possible, then you are on the side of pain, disorder and violence.
You guys are helping to prove point. This claim has no supporting evidence and plainly states that if you disagree, you support more violence. The entirety of the argument is an appeal to emotion, with no data provided to support the conclusion.
I provided three separate studies showing it's limited effectiveness, but those just get thrown aside because of perceived bias. As if the police aren't also biased to support more funding for their department.
Ordo specifically called out the "benefit" of emergency services getting somewhere faster. The article I shared has the data. In the first 8 months of 2024, there were almost 30,000 Shot Spotter alerts. From those, 143 victims received aid. 136 of those (95%) also had a 911 call. That means that 29,850 times, there was no victim. That seems like a lot of wasted resources. I'm open to seeing more data, but nobody has provided it in this discussion.
You guys are helping to prove point. This claim has no supporting evidence and plainly states that if you disagree, you support more violence. The entirety of the argument is an appeal to emotion, with no data provided to support the conclusion.
I provided three separate studies showing it's limited effectiveness, but those just get thrown aside because of perceived bias. As if the police aren't also biased to support more funding for their department.
Ordo specifically called out the "benefit" of emergency services getting somewhere faster. The article I shared has the data. In the first 8 months of 2024, there were almost 30,000 Shot Spotter alerts. From those, 143 victims received aid. 136 of those (95%) also had a 911 call. That means that 29,850 times, there was no victim. That seems like a lot of wasted resources. I'm open to seeing more data, but nobody has provided it in this discussion.
I'm not saying that ShotSpotter doesn't work, I am saying that nobody has ever proven that it works. That is probably why cities (Charlotte, San Antonio, Atlanta, etc.) continue to cancel contracts. Do we believe violence in Chicago has improved since the implementation of ShotSpotter in 2012?