seamusmcduff
Member
Definitely disappointing, Vancouver has a serious lack of pools. Unless you count all the private pools in condos.
Yes there was a 25-metre lane pool in the 2019 proposal
![]()
https://www.urbanyvr.com/new-langara-ymca-details/
A bit disappointing that there isn't a pool included in the YMCA space. This area, and South Vancouver generally, is really lacking in aquatics space.
I listen to the radio too much, but they were talking about this subject a few weeks ago, how Vancouver is lacking so many public pools and rinks etc. They talked about how so many other cities in Canada have much better facilities and much smaller populations and Vancouver really needs to get caught up.
I think community cenres aren't the greatest use of taxes? I feel like that's something that could be better handled by the private sector. Pools especially are giant money holes, but I understand the public benefit. What I don't like is the strategy of cities building so many amenities funded by levies on new housing. That is super unsustainable. I'd rather it be exclusively from property taxes. If people want to pay more taxes that's fine by me, but personally I don't mind them not existing. I would rather that money be spent on economically productive projects like transit or education.
Small amenities like outdoor pools, parks, sports venues etc are great. It becomes problematic when your city is spending over $250M on vanity projects like CG Brown in Burnaby. Imagine how much transit or new classrooms could be funded with that money. We need those for a functioning society, an olympic sized pool? That's more of discretionary.
You don't have to go far. Most of the burbs are better than Vancouver.
Not that our facilities all suck. Hillcrest is still amazing, we just need about 3 more of them.
Consider yourself in the minority.
Vancouver collects giant CAC payments from developers. They need to be more for things like community centres, pools, etc. Less art and other crap.
I think community cenres aren't the greatest use of taxes? I feel like that's something that could be better handled by the private sector.
The private sector will never fill the gap of community/rec centres/pools in Vancouver. The land costs are far too high for it to ever make sense. There's just no way it would be profitable (which they shouldn't be trying to be anyways).
What developer would choose a rec centre with a large footprint over residential buildings that fetch $1000 psf?
Okay but hear me out, what if a developer were to develop residential buildings on an existing recreation center and in exchange for being allowed to do so and therefore profit from said residential buildings, they have to build a pool.
Wild idea right?
The redevelopment like this one is a very rare opportunity I agree, and we should be getting as much as possible out of it, but it's still only replacing an existing rec centre. We need at least 3 or 4 brand new ones in the City considering our population growth, which isn't going to be done by the private sector.
Public art doesn't require maintenance or staff. Instead of swimming pools I think we need more pickleball courts.
The private market does add amenities like gyms, for example. You'll rarely see a private pool open to the public because pools are just extremely expensive to run. Again, fund that via property taxes if the people really want it, just don't tax new housing to build it.
Is it just pools you're against? I don't get it. Community centres fill a need in cities with all kinds of classes, warming/cooling in bad weather, etc.
I don't think YMCA and a developer should be responsible for providing a pool for the city. If they want to build one, great, but the YMCA would probably direct funds to fund other uses, than a pool. They can probably run more programs that way.