Heavy Rail, Commuter Rail, & Intercity Transportation


Evergreen Line peak daily ridership: 39,500.
West Coast Express peak daily ridership: 10,400

The people of Vancouver know what's really most efficient for them.
 
Evergreen Line peak daily ridership: 39,500.
West Coast Express peak daily ridership: 10,400

The people of Vancouver know what's really most efficient for them.

Yeah but the WCE has limited service, 10 per day in both directions, 5 westbound and 5 eastbound in the morning and evening respectively. To me this doesn't seem like a fair comparison.
 
Yeah but the WCE has limited service, 10 per day in both directions, 5 westbound and 5 eastbound in the morning and evening respectively. To me this doesn't seem like a fair comparison.

Commuter trains in general don't run as often as their respective metro lines (hourly is considered "frequent"); they also don't cover all the in-between that commuters might also want to reach. The WCE's really only good for racing from Mission or Maple Ridge all the way downtown and back, and that's a relatively small niche.
 
Yeah but the WCE has limited service, 10 per day in both directions, 5 westbound and 5 eastbound in the morning and evening respectively. To me this doesn't seem like a fair comparison.

WCE is also not a high speed service or even "higher" speed service. It takes an hour twenty to go 67km from downtown to Mission which means it averages around 50km/hr which isn't much faster than the average Skytrain speed even though it's an express limited stop service. In fact unless traffic is exceptionally bad it's not even all that much faster than driving. It doesn't help that it has to snake along the waterfront and condend with level crossings.

I'm not going to crunch any numbers because the cost would probably be staggering, but if there were to be higher speed service out of Vancouver towards the SoF communities, I think the ridership would be much greater.
 
I'll say it again: the last time BC studied the interurban, they only found 3,900 riders/day. The express bus option had an even 4k.

Granted, the interurban sucks, but I highly doubt a better alignment will reach quintuple digits unless Abbotsford and Chilliwack get another two decades' worth of growth, not to mention un-sprawl themselves and fix their local bus networks. Until then, it's more FVX service and transit lanes.
 
I'll say it again: the last time BC studied the interurban, they only found 3,900 riders/day. The express bus option had an even 4k.

Granted, the interurban sucks, but I highly doubt a better alignment will reach quintuple digits unless Abbotsford and Chilliwack get another two decades' worth of growth, not to mention un-sprawl themselves and fix their local bus networks. Until then, it's more FVX service and transit lanes.

I don't believe I mentioned the interurban. The biggest reason the interurban is a horrible idea is because it meanders and just isn't competitive with driving or really any other form of transit. If there were to be a hypothetical direct rapid(er) transit solution, the ridership numbers would certainly be higher (but also probably not high enough to justify the cost.)
 
I'm simply using it as the benchmark, since it's the only number for Valley ridership. No doubt a direct route would fare better, but not much better without significant increases in TOD and feeder bus service.
 
This is kinda out there but I imagine tunnel boring from Downtown with stops at Metrotown, Surrey, Langley and Abbotsford would be a lot cheaper than doing something similar above ground, should the tunneling be done much deeper. Isn't tunnel boring much cheaper to do when you're not going directly under pipes and other infrastructure? Like with the tunnel on the Evergreen extension?
 
The tunnel and rails in themselves are pretty steep, and deeper just makes it pricier. Evergreen's tunnel was "cheap" because there's only 2km of it.

At any rate, UBCx's tunnel bore is pegged at $160m/km; assuming a straight line from Pacific Central to Metrotown, then Surrey Central, then Langley Station, that's about 35.6 km, or $5.7 billion; there to Sevenoaks is another $4.2 billion on top of that. Whalley-Abbotsford might be doable one day, but for now, even the downtown streetcar has a better business case.
 
The WCE's really only good for racing from Mission or Maple Ridge all the way downtown and back, and that's a relatively small niche.

It stops in Pitt Meadows, Port Coquitlam, Coquitlam, and Port Moody also. I use it regularly as do thousands of others including people I know.

It needs to have all day service in both directions, weekend service and extensions. Even with the train-sets they have they could much better service with a few strategic track upgrades.

The inbound train yesterday morning was almost standing room only.
 

So does the R3, and by many accounts, is as fast (on the highway) as the WCE.

All of said upgrades are constrained by limited space west of Coquitlam, and by the cost of expansion east of it. I recognize that over five thousand people depend on it every day... while also recognizing that many of the same people would benefit from an Evergreen extension to Port Coq, and that hundreds of thousands more somewhere else would benefit from SkyTrain to UBC or Lonsdale. Everybody's standing room only these days.
 
why would we expand the WCE when its currently at like 1/2 of its pre-pandemic ridership still? maybe when(if) it breaks even, we can talk about expanding it then. otherwise its a legacy service that has some serious questions on if its still even worth it.
 
Evergreen Line peak daily ridership: 39,500.
West Coast Express peak daily ridership: 10,400

The people of Vancouver know what's really most efficient for them.

Not a fair comparison in any way, shape, or form. 5 one-way trains during the commute vs. 15 bi-directional trains / hour, that effectively connects to two separate lines.

The fact that the WCE is as high as 25% of the EGL is remarkable.
 
Not a fair comparison in any way, shape, or form. 5 one-way trains during the commute vs. 15 bi-directional trains / hour, that effectively connects to two separate lines.

The fact that the WCE is as high as 25% of the EGL is remarkable.

By the same logic, the WCE connects to three separate lines (Expo, Canada, SeaBus) at Waterfront. At last check the conversation's about efficiency, and 1,400 people/train means that even bi-directional hourly service from Waterfront to Mission isn't going to reach the Evergreen's 39.5k, let alone its maximum theoretical capacity; it can barely even get back to 50% of pre-pandemic ridership.
 
i think this is the key right here on any talk of WCE expansion.

if it cant get back to where it was, with the same service it had back then, how can it be justified for expansion?

I'd say if the service is still at 50% PPL then perhaps it's time to look at replacing it with a full time extension of the 701 to provide all day service to Mission or to just bustitute the WCE with it's own dedicated route.
 
I'd say if the service is still at 50% PPL then perhaps it's time to look at replacing it with a full time extension of the 701 to provide all day service to Mission or to just bustitute the WCE with it's own dedicated route.

Proposing to replace a heavy rail commuter train with a bus is the most neoliberal starve-the-beast solution to a problem. It will just kill the line completely. Part of the reason people take the train is so they don't have to be stuck in traffic dealing with congestion and delays.

The WCE is a fundamentally crippled rail line that needs to be made bidirectional and serve the purpose of transit in that regard. Ridership would only go up if it were a true rail service that connected communities instead of shifting commuters one way, then eventually the other.

Sadly the WCE is the closest thing we have in the Lower Mainland to a proper intercity rail system and letting it die will only delay or destroy a needed category of transit in our region. These kinds of systems work all over the world and people seem to think that doing it wrong is good evidence for not doing it at all.
 
Sadly the WCE is the closest thing we have in the Lower Mainland to a proper intercity rail system and letting it die will only delay or destroy a needed category of transit in our region. These kinds of systems work all over the world and people seem to think that doing it wrong is good evidence for not doing it at all.

People think that "doing it right" isn't worth a billion or two which could go to something more important. As it is, we're still waiting on funding for UBCx and the North Shore Line which'd each move 100x more people.

The objective is to get people from the exurbs in and out of the city, and the problem is that very few commuters want to go from Maple Ridge and Mission all the way to downtown these days; if TransLink (eventually) studies it and finds bus lanes on Highway 7 and R3s every 5-10 minutes can do that just as well for less money, then unless you can convince Ottawa to stop blowing all the federal transit money on Greater Toronto, let's not be fixated on having trains for the sake of having trains.
 
People think that "doing it right" isn't worth a billion or two which could go to something more important. As it is, we're still waiting on funding for UBCx and the North Shore Line which'd each move 100x more people.

The objective is to get people from the exurbs in and out of the city, and the problem is that very few commuters want to go from Maple Ridge and Mission all the way to downtown these days; if TransLink (eventually) studies it and finds bus lanes on Highway 7 and R3s every 5-10 minutes can do that just as well for less money, then unless you can convince Ottawa to stop blowing all the federal transit money on Greater Toronto, let's not be fixated on having trains for the sake of having trains.

Fixated on having trains for the sake of having trains?

We have over 340,000 people out here in the Fraser Valley and it is growing an average 5000-8000 per year. What are we supposed to do? Just use the highway system as a parking lot because there is no other option planned?
We need comprehensive intercity transit. Look at our neighbours to the south. King County built nothing but highways everywhere and now it's just gridlock and they are panic building over 100km of rapid transit in every direction to try and get ahead of it.

Now we sit and make the same mistakes year over year. Sure, let's do nothing, or better yet, let's get rid of the paltry rail transit we already have and integrate it with the already dysfunctional freeway system. That'll get people out of their cars.

Having a higher population in one area doesn't permanently preclude the needs of others. The Fraser Valley is looking for the bare minimum. We don't even have good transit by Victorian standards. We are looking for what is seen as a bare bones necessity in many places around the world.

Vancouver needs transit. So does Victoria. So does Kelowna, and the other interior cities. So does the Fraser Valley. Unfortunately the rest of us go without and are told "it's not needed."

Ever take transit in the valley? It took me three hours to travel 60 kilometers into Vancouver relying on the transit we have out here. Ridiculous and embarrassing.
 

And it's not your fault that the Valley based the last seven decades' worth of transportation/city planning on those two highways solving everything forever.

By the same token though, it's not TransLink's fault that the Valley is now heavily car-dependent, allergic to transit and walkability (and the kind of planning that encourages those), and aside from Mission, unwilling to even pay for more bus/train service while they simultaneously demand it.

Cool. We in Vancouver see your 5-8k and raise you 36-37k.
I'll say it again: the WCE gets 5.3k riders/day. The interurban is pegged at 3.9k/day. The 502 from Surrey to Langley has 5.6k/day, which is about to balloon to 56k+ That's the baseline we're dealing with.
Insisting the entire province pay for a train that performs worse than a bus because it's "what you're owed" is not realistic. You're not the only people in the province. Everybody's stuck in traffic.

You want to increase transit in the Valley to justify a train? Alright. First do what Vancouver did and fix the crappy Flying Spaghetti Monster bus networks (over 70% of drivers in Mission stay in Mission, and that number's even higher for Abbotsford and Chilliwack, so commuter rail won't fix that), start building up lowrises and midrises along the buses, and then run more frequent express service between the cities and to Metro Vancouver; the current TCH expansion is adding bus lanes, so no getting stuck in traffic.
If Ottawa one day feels generous and decides to blow $28 billion on trains in BC (the cost of one single subway in Ontario), go ahead and have your WCE expansion; until then, we all have to earn our turns instead.
 


Back
Top