DENVER | Main Development Thread #7


40 units an acre is not that much! That's like four story apartments, borderline to what could support above ground structured parking or still need surface. It's not sprawl but it's not enough to both profit on its own and subsidize a garage with hundreds of extra spaces for park n ride.

Maybe averaged over a whole big neighborhood with a dozen blocks of development like at Alameda that would be enough density. But not for a single property. Not if you're trying to make this pencil based solely on redeveloping the park n ride itself. That's high-rise territory.
 
I count 174 cars parked in the Central Park n Ride in the photo accompanying the article.

RTD should have a planning estimate for the number of likely riders they'll get from each unit. I'm going to guess it's something like 0.2 riders/day/unit. Just an educated guess. At that rate, 800 units would result in 160 riders/day.

So assuming my guess is roughly accurate, that's fine as long as they're not eliminating the parking for those 174 cars. But if they are eliminating the parking, then they need a lot more units. Which may or may not be possible under zoning.

That kind of calculation has to happen at every one of these. Easy enough, but they probably don't all pencil out.

It might be something more than 0.2 riders/unit. Public transportation utilization is probably somewhere around 20-25% for a location like this in Denver (yes very low but high compared to our roughly 7% overall public transport utilization). Assuming maybe 1.4 occupants/unit that gets us to roughly 0.3 riders per unit. With simple 5 story zoning, you could probably push a podium building or wrap to around 140 maybe 150 units/acre if the parking were relaxed. RTD owns at least 15 developable acres at Central Park (more if you got rid of solar parking). Without even trying, RTD could sell those lots and see 5 story development of AT MINIMUM 2,100 units. At 0.3 riders/unit, that would equate to at least 630 riders. What RTD will say is, BUT WE HAVE 1,500 PARKING SPACES (WAAAAHHHH). If that location were to go mid-rise (12 stories and below), you could easily see 4-5k units in that small area with 1,500 daily riders, way more than their currently empty parking lots.
 
RTD could pay for their own garages while allowing developers to develop housing. If housing supply is a major goal, or housing near transit, this is a slam dunk. It's only debatable if the goal is making money for the agency.

Let's say they can get $300/sf for eight acres, eliminating 1,200 surface parking spaces. The land deal is $104,544,000. (Hugely variable of course)

If they need a 1,500-space garage for a 1:1 replacement, that can easily cost more than the land sale. I'd guess this could be in the $120-150,000,000 range. (The Seattle area builds PR garages for $100,000 per space.)

Of course if you can cut the parking by 2/3 it'll be much easier.
 
I do agree that 40 dwelling units per acre is not actually that much - although many suburbs were making the case that the new legislation should reduce that target to only 20 dwelling units per acre because they "can't support the infrastructure for 40 dua." I found such a stance ridiculous (cities can always assess impact fees to pay for infrastructure), and evidence that these municipalities don't take transit seriously if they are unwilling to zone for transit-supportive density.

Whether that is enough density for a developer to build structured parking and turn a profit is a different question. But as mhays points out, there are other ways to make this pencil out if RTD is willing to partner on the cost of the garage or find another way to save the developer money (discounted land deal maybe?).

I'm not sure what the net achievable density is under C-MX-16, but this zoning allows for up to a 16-story building, so I think this specific zone district would likely allow density well above the 40 dua target.
 
If I recall correctly, wasn't part of the problem for many years that RTD actually had to change its bylaws in order to allow the sale of these parking lots?

I don't think TOD was ever explicitly precluded, but I seem to remember that RTD had organizational rules that both required the majority of their revenue to come from the farebox (meaning they couldn't charge extra at park-n-rides that have higher parking demand), and that also effectively prohibited the sale of land that had been funded as a part of FasTracks. Perhaps somebody else remembers these exact changes better than I do, but I recall in the news that their board approved these structural changes only somewhat recently.

The irony of having a rule that required a certain percentage of revenue to come from the farebox, at the exclusion of TOD land deals, is embedded in Cirrus' point. If 800 units would result in 160 riders/day, and enough structured parking can be provided to account for those 174 existing park-n-ride riders, this actually INCREASES the potential farebox revenue. It was the sort of policy that stood in the way of its own objective, and was leading to a kind of death-spiral. If the goal is actually to increase the revenue coming from fares, it would stand to reason that this should come from increased ridership. Instead, I recall that they used to have to increase fares to make the budget balance, which was hurting ridership instead.

RTD's policy is generally a 1/1 replacement of parking spaces IF you can make a deal with them (which really isn't possible). RTD doesn't factor in that replacement cost when determining the value of their land so they basically require a crap ton of money for parking and a crap ton of money for land - it's not feasible. This is the major issue. They need to amend their bylaws - really they need an entire structural overhaul. It would honestly be easier to kill RTD and replace it with a new transit agency which is more appropriate because Denver could/should negotiate better service terms in that transition and stick the middle finger up high to all of the suburbs which gut Denver's service standards.
 
Could Denver County hold the sales tax it collects for RTD at ransom? Or even threaten to cancel the tax entirely.

If possible, it seems like a power dynamic is not being deployed at the expense of Denver's citizens.
 
"Everything Must Change; Nothing Stays the Same"
(Quincy Jones ft Tommy Körberg with Sarah Dawn Finer)

The young become the old
And mysteries do unfold
'Cause that's the way of time
Nothing and no one goes unchanged



TakeFive isn't banned for precisely these reasons. The only action taken was to split off the other thread and ask everyone to try and talk development here and other stuff there.

TakeFive has not said a word to me since I shut down the part of the thread where ten different people were calling for me to ban him. He may have left on his own accord after reading those messages. I have no idea. But he is not banned.
This literally is the 1st time I've jumped on the site since I wrote my "passing the torch" comment.

I don't take anything personally. But I've known for some time it would be good for everybody if I took a good long vacation.

For some of the so-called long-timers it may not be as long as many of us. Cirrus sequestering comments is NOT a new thing. I can recall years ago when this site went (way) off topic for ~ three pages of comments. Cirrus would come along and sequester all those comments to a sub-thread.

Life goes on.

Summer Siesta

When the temps hit 110 degrees I relax at home more. I thought about joining Netflix for a month or two but decided 'Nah'. Not to worry, while I'll add some flavor in the short term, I'm committed to being more of a lurker at this point.

There has been a number of developments not mentioned. There's also a number of developing developments that will impact future development - along the lines of stuff laniroj brings up. Not sure how much time... we'll see.
 
It was laniroj who brought up the concept of 15-minute city/neighborhoods. I wasn't so familiar with the notion... but I am now.

There's More To 15-Minute City Conspiracies Than You Think
June 10, 2024 by Amber DaSilva - Jalopnik
It’s urban design that prioritizes people over parking, but it’s also a phrase that’s launched a thousand absurd conspiracy theories. Why are people getting so riled up over urban planning?
BTW, it helps if you have a (good) sense of humor.
Well, they’re not — not really, anyway. The conspiracy theories are less about the realities of 15-minute cities, and more about their imagined position as the first step in a grand UN-backed plan to imprison humanity and depopulate the Earth.
This video is awesome
How do you get from such an innocuous point A to such an absurd plan B? Abigail Thorn of Philosophy Tube has an incredibly cool-sounding explanation: All those conspiracy theorists are caught in a phantasm.
While the video is just short of an hour it is entertaining and well produced.
 
533 luxury apartments open in Jefferson Park. Ten Denver teachers will get free rent
Jun. 28, 2024 By Kyle Harris -- Denverite
Renting at Skyline at Highlands looks like a great life — for those who can afford it. You can rent a studio apartment for a mere $1,899. A one-bedroom starting at $2,049
a month. Two bedrooms start at $3,189.

I have plenty to say about Affordability - if/when I get to it. But lets first celebrate the Grand Opening for a project that was a longtime-coming.

Skyline at Highlands
2501 W 26th Ave
Located in the popular Highlands neighborhood, Skyline offers mountain views, walkable dining and nightlife, and lifestyle-focused amenities make every moment memorable.

image.png


image.jpg


image.jpg


image.jpg

Images courtesy Grand Peaks/Skyline at Highlands (via ForRent)

This project had quite the development history. Some may remember the construction equipment including cranes that littered the property for a few years. The 'original' developer
was from NYC; he had previously built projects in the DU area including a nice newer project along So University. This goes back in decade or longer. I recall doing some research
and the guy (I forget his name) was struggling with some newer projects he developed in NYC.

Then along came Grand Peaks (and other partners). I believe a number of units are reserved for Sonder who Grand Peaks works with on other projects.

Anyway it's nice to see this project is now finished.

I found it:

Grand Peaks Brings Sonder to Skyline at Highlands, Offering Short-Term Rentals and Apartment-Style Hotel Stays
DENVER, May 16, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- Grand Peaks, a fully integrated real estate investment firm, announced the recent lease of 93 units within their forthcoming luxury
multifamily community, Skyline at Highlands, to Sonder. Sonder is a leader in short-term rentals, offering apartment-style hotel stays in active urban areas. Skyline at Highlands,
located at 2501 W 26th Ave in Denver's LoHi neighborhood, is pre-leasing the remainder of its 533 units now and is poised to become a true mixed-use destination
with hospitality, luxury living and a full suite of amenities opening in June.

The 93-room hotel marks Sonder's fourth project in LoHi and will offer guests a blend of contemporary design and convenience. Guests at the hotel will have access to an array
of the apartment community's luxury amenities, including a resort-style pool and hot tub, a state-of-the-art fitness center and expansive open park spaces.
 
Last edited:
Bye Bye Lennar Multifamily aka Quarterra

KKR Makes $2.1B Apartment Buy
June 26, 2024 By Emily Wishingrad, Bisnow Washington, D.C.
Investment giant KKR has scooped up more than 5,000 apartments across the country in a deal that represents its biggest-ever bet on the sector.

The 5,200 units are spread across several states, including California, Washington, Florida, Texas, Georgia and North Carolina, Colorado and New Jersey.

Note: This sale only involved half of what Lennar put up For Sale.
It comes six months after Quarterra’s parent company, Lennar, announced it was looking to sell more than 11,000 apartment properties that Quarterra operates
Since Colorado was included in this sale I assume it includes all the Denver projects.

Let's celebrate my favorite Lennar/Quarterra project

Citizen West 10
140 West 10th Ave.

Citizen%20Drone-April%2020%2C%202022250-2.jpg

Image courtesy Quarterra formally Lennar Multifamily

QUARTERRA NEWS
Quarterra is proud to announce that Citizen West 10 was named the 2023 Multifamily Development of the Year CoStar Impact Award winner in the Denver market. Citizen is among an elite group of winners — chosen for growth, diversification, and ability to overcome unique challenges — selected by a panel of more than 750 industry professionals drawn from each respective market.

Citizen, a high-rise community in Denver’s historic Golden Triangle neighborhood — the city’s hub for art, culture and civic institutions — features 393 luxury apartment homes and townhomes. Residents are just steps from art museums and galleries, history museums and Civic Center Park. With spectacular mountain and city views, Citizen positions residents to take in the best that the city and region have to offer.
 
Latest concept plan submission for 1800 Welton - Amacon phase 2:

Two 39 story towers, 613 residential units, 91 hotel rooms, 10,000 square feet of retail, 423 feet in height:

1800_Welton_Rendering_070324-1.jpg


1800_Welton_Rendering_070324-2.jpg


1800_Welton_Rendering_070324-3.jpg
 
It's pretty crazy that one developer is building 1,000 condos and every other developer is building 0. I hope they make a miniature model and place it in the sales center. Miniatures are amazing.
 
Just going from memory; too lazy to double check
If I recall correctly, wasn't part of the problem for many years that RTD actually had to change its bylaws in order to allow the sale of these parking lots?
A) Seems I read just recently that RTD had been required to sell any land at fair market value. That has now been changed allowing RTD to sell their Five Points land at a lower price to enable an affordable housing project.

B) PLANSIT has stated in the past that for suburban park-n-rides that those spaces were required by the FTA. I assume that means they would have to give their permission for changes. If the feasibility of project was based on having park-n-rides that could be a challenge.

C) In some cases RTD bought ROW before they had made final determination for siting stations etc.

D) It turns out that RTD sometimes ended up with more land than necessary. That occurred as RTD bought up ROW like a whole parcel/site from the previous owner. Sellers were NOT interested in selling all but a sliver here or there of their land.

Denver’s train network was built for car commuters. With parking lots empty, RTD thinks housing could help save it
During RTD’s rail-building era, it went all in on drivers and their cars.
I hesitate to rag on Nathaniel Minor too much; he's a good writer and he does know Denver's transit history. But he just can't resist going into anti-car mode. That headline is misleading while oddly also being generally true.

A) None of our esteemed transit fans ever want or are willing to talk about "First- and Last-Mile" problems. Fact is it's one of the more critical things impacting ridership.

B) FasTracks was built as a suburb to city mostly spoke and wheel system. Yes, "car commuters" interested in the convenience of light rail needed their 'first mile issue' addressed which park-n-rides do.

C) Prior to FasTacks there was the SW corridor line and later the SE corridor line. With the SW Line ridership projections were smashed out-of-the gate and parking spaces were taken by 8 AM at the latest at the Mineral Station with parking overflowing into the neighborhoods. Use of park-n-rides was also impressive along the SE rail lines, notably Nine Mile Station and Lincoln Station.

With respect to First- and Last-Mile issues

According to Transit Guru Jarrett Walker/Human Transit
basics: walking distance to transit

If you have to choose a single walking distance standard for all situations, the most commonly cited standard is 400m or 1/4 mi.
 
Latest concept plan submission for 1800 Welton - Amacon phase 2:

Two 39 story towers, 613 residential units, 91 hotel rooms, 10,000 square feet of retail, 423 feet in height:

1800_Welton_Rendering_070324-1.jpg

Thanks for posting RDS. I'm excited for these projects, I really am, but for the life of me I cannot understand why these are such bland/boring aesthetics compared to their other stuff in Canada. My determination is that Denver just has bland/boring architects who don't know how to make this scale/size of building look good. Other may disagree, but that's my take. I wish these larger projects would use true high rise architects with experience, which is definitely not the local architecture crowd.
 
To date I have given Mayor Mike high marks

But with respect to my Five Votes he's now pushing his luck.

Denver mayor proposes sales tax increase to expand affordable housing
Jul 08, 2024 By: Brandon Richard -- 7Denver News
DENVER — November’s ballot is getting longer and taxes could be getting higher. On Monday, Denver Mayor Mike Johnston announced a new ballot proposal that would increase the city’s sales tax by 0.5% to provide more affordable housing.

He said it would bring in $100 million per year, helping the city provide 44,000 housing units over the next decade.

It sounds nice but I'd have many concerns; for starters I don't want to lose focus on the homeless etc problems. I'm also more specifically concerned with converting downtown office building to apartments but that's still in the early planning stages.

My early feelings is that it's (way) too big and I wouldn't be in favor of a 'forever' tax.

-----------------------------

With respect to adding apartments at RTD’s Central Park park-and-ride

I was curious about this:
The Regional Transportation District board of directors will vote next week on whether to go into exclusive negotiations with the Ulysses Development Group, which has proposed building more than 800 units of affordable housing on top of part of the underused Central Park park-and-ride.
I was curious about who Ulysses Development Group is. Their focus is on Workforce Housing which sounds fine. They have a rather thin resume of completed projects to date. I do like the complex they built in So Phoenix just west of 16th street. It's called Salt River Flats.
 
Celebrating the recent completion of two beautiful AA Office Buildings

Would you like to guess?

dlr0008-s06-terrace-wip04_1.jpg


I'm sure this will help!

19la-tower-01a.jpg

Images courtesy 1900 Lawrence

https://denvergazette.com/news/busi...cle_dc767a56-3efc-11ef-ab81-af3752df1fc0.html
A 700,000-square-foot building downtown on 1900 Lawrence Street finished construction during the second quarter and was completely empty upon completion, the report said, leading to a spike in Class A office building vacancies. The building’s only pre-committed tenant isn’t expected to move into its space until 2025.

-------------------------------

RiNo’s Newest Destination Workplace Now Complete
May 31, 2024 By Katie Rapone, editor Mile High CRE
As tenants in 2024 raise their expectations for office space, emphasizing outdoor space, advanced technology, and premium amenities, Paradigm River North — a LEED-Gold, 188,000-square-foot Class AA office building in RiNo — is designed to meet every requirement.

Developers Jordon Perlmutter & Co. and Rockefeller Group have officially announced that construction is now complete. Located at 3400 Walnut Street, the office building recently completed an 80,000-square-foot pre-lease with the law firm Davis Graham & Stubbs LLP. The firm secured the top three floors of the eight-story building.

PARADIGM RIVER NORTH
3400 Walnut Street

7023fe_b3c8329898714039ba09a2c428b0aabb~mv2_d_2000_1600_s_2.jpg


Paradigm-River-North-Office-Building.png

Images courtesy Jordon Perlmutter & Co. and Rockefeller Group

Postscript: I sincerely hope the Perlmutter family does well with this investment. I had the opportunity of meeting and working on a deal with their Dad. Jordie was a 'salt of the earth' type person; he was very gracious, very professional.
 
Not counting Cherry Creek how many office buildings in the downtown area are yet to complete?

Only a couple come to mind, one smaller and one medium-sized, both in RiNo.

3083-Walnut-St-Denver-CO-Building-Photo-1-Large.jpg

Image courtesy Mortenson

https://www.mortenson.com/projects/3083-walnut-street
Mortenson is underway on the development and construction of a new four-story, 65,000 square foot mixed-use building in Denver’s River North Art District (RiNo). The project includes three floors of Class A office space, ground floor retail and a 95-stall parking garage with two levels below-grade. Mortenson will occupy approximately 37,000 square feet and lease out the remaining space to third-party tenants.
Mortenson plans to occupy the middle two floors and lease out the top floor for office space and the ground floor for retail. Their ETA was 4th quarter of 2024.

Steel House
3100 Brighton Blvd

9.8D-Steel-House-exterior.png

Image courtesy Steel House -- Morris Adjmi and Open Studio Architecture

https://milehighcre.com/300000-sqft-office-project-breaks-ground-in-rino/
...Beacon Capital Partners and Denver-based Elevation Development Group have broken ground on Steel House. The 12-story, 300,000-square-foot office and retail project, located at 3100 Brighton Blvd in RiNo... The industrial biophilic design, by Morris Adjmi and Open Studio Architecture, wraps around the largest elevated private park in RiNo. The building’s silhouette reflects RiNo’s storied industrial history, with up to 41,000 square-foot floor plates framed by expansive floor-to-ceiling windows that open onto private tenant terraces.

--------------------------------------

With Respect to Cherry Creek

After a marathon of analysis through mountains and valleys and many, many late nights of debate -- A DECISION HAS BEEN MADE.

WELCOME TO YOUR NEW 15-MINUTE COMMUNITY—CHERRY CREEK WEST


Thanks to Streetsblog's Blake Aued, ever the humorist

Friday’s Headlines Will Be There in 15 Minutes
We promise: Whether you live in a 15-minute city or a 20-minute suburb, you will be allowed to leave.
 
Updating the state of office space

Hot off the Press:
The Colorado Trust Relocates HQ to The Hub North in RiNo
July 16, 2024
Tributary Real Estate, a commercial real estate brokerage firm based in Colorado, announced the successful lease negotiation for The Colorado Trust‘s new 14,000-square-foot, full-floor headquarters at The Hub North in RiNo.

The Colorado Trust is a private philanthropic foundation that was founded in 1985 and makes grants statewide. The foundation’s mission is to advance the health and well-being of people living in Colorado. The Colorado Trust engaged Tributary to help identify a new office that would increase workplace efficiencies while supporting its team and the communities it serves.
The Colorado Trust is currently located at 1600 Sherman St.

Johns Manville Signs New Lease to Keep World Headquarters in Denver
May. 08, 2024
DENVER—Wednesday, May 8, 2024—Johns Manville (JM), a leading manufacturer of premium-quality building and specialty products and a Berkshire Hathaway company, announced today its world headquarters will stay in downtown Denver through at least 2035. The company renewed a lease with Brookfield Properties for over 121,000 square feet of space on five floors in the high-rise building at 717 17th St.

JM moved to Denver in July 1988. Over 300 employees work at the world headquarters building, supporting corporate functions such as finance, information technology, supply chain, human resources and legal.
Certainly, Mayor Mike was pleased.
“We are thrilled that Johns Manville and its employees have made a strategic and intentional decision to remain in the heart of our downtown corridor,” said Denver Mayor Mike Johnston. “In addition to retaining their global headquarters, 300 jobs, and other economic benefits for our community, Johns Manville's re-commitment and investment in a downtown Denver location represents an opportunity to support growth and stabilization in our city center.”

The Mayor’s Office and the Downtown Denver Partnership both offered support in recent months as JM pursued information related to safety, construction, traffic and parking.
I wonder if Warren Buffett signed off on this? Has he ever even seen the space? Good grief; it's a short hop by plane from Omaha.

Colorado Chamber Announces Move to New Office Space
April 23, 2024
DENVER – The Colorado Chamber of Commerce today announced it is relocating to a new office building in downtown Denver. The organization will be moving to the fifth floor of 1700 Broadway at the Atrium Campus effective in June 2024.

The new office will include a more collaborative workspace for employees, technology upgrades to better connect statewide Chamber members, additional individual office space to support team growth, and an expanded conference room with enhanced video and audio technology capabilities. These features will help facilitate the implementation of the Colorado Chamber’s 10-year strategic action plan to improve the state’s business climate.

---------------------------------

comme ci comme ça

Meta aka Facebook
has decided to vacate its two floors at at 1900 16th Street amounting to ~47,000 Sq Ft but will turn around and lease 24,000 Sq Ft on the Top Floor of this building.

Whole Foods
is moving its Regional Headquarters from 3012 Huron St. to 1500 Wynkoop St. and downsize by ~ 25,000 less Sq Ft in the process.
 
joey-friends.gif


Looking at You, Colorado

These 10 U.S. states have America’s best economies in 2024
JUL 18 2024 By Scott Cohn -- CNBC
10. Delaware -- 9. Idaho -- 8. Nevada -- 7. Georgia -- 6. Utah
5. Arizona -- 4. North Carolina -- 3. Tennessee -- 2. Texas -- 1. Florida
Kind of tells a Red State story doesn't it?

Interestingly Colorado's ranking at 16th is much better than last year's ranking (32nd) but only the Shadow knows why.

America’s Top States for Business 2024: The full rankings
JUL 11 2024 -- CNBC

Colorado's composite ranking is 16th this year as compared to 11th last year so they continue to drop in the rankings. But being rated in the Top 20 is still respectable.

Last year for grins I also looked at Washington and Arizona. Washington has dropped from 7th last year to 10th this year. Arizona rose from 14th last year to 12th this year so not much of a move up. After ten years of trying to make the state more business friendly they have improved each of the last two years. But being business friendly is not weighted that much.

Colorado's lowest rankings this year are for "Cost of Doing Business" at 39th and "Business Friendliness" at 32nd but both are low rated in importance.

Fortunately for Colorado, the two highest weighted rankings are for "Infrastructure" and "Work Force" where Colorado ranks 12th and 11th.

Notes:

If you're curious about methodology you can find that HERE.

I did discover last year that these ranking have a bit of a 'liberal' bias but perhaps justifiably so. For example, with Infrastructure 'resilience' including renewable energy is a factor. Also Airports.

So far the economy remains good including in Colorado. We're probably at the peak of iija money. Not sure the CHIPS and Science Act will be meaningful for Colorado but some help. The IRA money may take a hit depending on the election but it's speculative what that might mean - to Colorado.
 
Last edited:


Back
Top