I'm a big believer in PATH expansion but with NJTransit I don't think extending past EWR makes much sense.
You saw this pre-pandemic when there was a horde of NJ Transit/Amtrak folks getting off at Newark and transferring to PATH to go to the WTC. The demand is there.
I'm a big believer in PATH expansion but with NJTransit I don't think extending past EWR makes much sense.
If PA wanted to fund it I wouldn't stand in the way. It would be a challenge squeezing it into the NEC r.o.w. but probably doable. Not to let the air out the balloon but considering how long it's taken them to even begin serious steps towards the stupefyingly obvious extension to EWR, unless an Elizabeth extension was packaged together with tremendous political support I don't see them moving on it.
March 2024 Ridership Numbers Just Released
March 2019
Avg. Weekday: 281,605
Saturday: 106,134
Sunday: 69,640
March 2024
Avg. Weekday: 177,646 (63% Recovered)
Saturday: 86,807 (81.8% Recovered)
Sunday: 72,350 (103.9% Recovered)
PATH should not be considered a commuter railroad! Weekend numbers are rising fast. PATH should have normal service instead of weekend service. Numbers would rise even higher.
On the plus side, NIMBYs have lost a credible claim about PATH overcrowding. Tens of thousands of units coming online and still not close to pre-pandemic ridership levels. Might as well keep adding until back up to 300,000 people a day and resume talks of expansion of service.
Will there ever be a scenario where weekend ridership matches or exceeds weekday service? The fact that we're seeing all time new highs on weekends, while weekdays continue to lag.
Take the Newark-WTC service to 10 minute headways from 20 on Saturdays and lets find out.
^ welp if you want to see the effects of wfh on the workweek and more desire for weekend service, which we all know anecdotally, there it is in real numbers.