Comrade
They all float down here
You being so adamant this project not happen, and that the city kick Ryan Smith to the curb, when you've got zero skin in the game is the point. You don't live in Salt Lake anymore. You're not going to be impacted one way or another. It's easy for you to say, "let Ryan Smith move the Jazz and this hockey team south or into Utah County..." when you don't actually live in Salt Lake County, let alone Salt Lake City.
That's the point. You're free to have an opinion and speak your mind but I just find it funny that you're so ready to go to war over things that haven't even been announced yet and you don't live here anymore. I'm sure you can see how that dynamic is a bit interesting.
And I'm not trying to be a dick. My whole point is that you're worried but you're not going to be the one who faces the long-term consequences of either option.
That's the reality.
So, it's easy to dismiss Ryan Smith and his proposal and to suggest he should pound sand.
But you're not the one who will have to potentially face a reality where the Jazz and the hockey team relocate to Provo. You're not the one who will have to potentially face a reality where downtown loses the Delta Center because Ryan Smith decides to bulldoze it so he doesn't have two competing arenas. Maybe they replace the arena with a four-story cookie-cutter apartment project, which I'm sure will totally make up for it.
It won't be you, tho, who has to worry about downtown stagnating now that it's losing over a million-plus people coming into the city a year for events at the Delta Center. It won't be your business that goes under because there's just not enough foot traffic anymore in that area. It won't be you that has to figure out how to incentivize downtown now that one of its major draws has completely relocated to the suburbs.
That's not something you'll have to worry about.
You won't have to worry about a tax base that might dwindle because downtown development kind of dries up with the area not being a destination anymore. Especially if it has to compete with The Point and that Utah City in Utah County.
Clearly the city sees some incentive in working with Ryan Smith or they wouldn't have decided to fight as hard for the Jazz like they have.
But it's not a coincidence downtown died when everyone's attention turned to the suburbs in the 1960s, 70s and 80s. They're not immune from that ever happening again.
Downtown has to continue to be proactive or it'll see the exact same decline that shuttered Main Street for so many years.
That doesn't mean give away the farm. But it does mean being open to ideas.
Why anyone would object to a billion-dollar investment into downtown is beyond me. I can understand concerns but when will Salt Lake ever get that commitment again?
Because it certainly hasn't happened outside the LDS Church and the Gateway, which was really pushed by federal dollars to clean up the Brownfields.
But outside that? How many mega projects are floated and never materialize?
That impacts the city and those who live here.