You're correct that Downtown Detroit is absolutely killing it, and Downtown Cleveland, while not the most vibrant city core, is still making huge strides and seeing a lot of new development.
I spent four days in Cleveland before Easter (for work) and downtown, while hardly booming, seemed in decent-ish shape. Certainly 100x better than STL. No abandoned stuff, everything along Euclid converted to apartments (not sure if this is an unabashedly good thing), and obviously that big new tower going up on Public Square. And the Flats seem sorta back.
The streets were pretty empty, most of the time and there were a fair amount of homeless. But it wasn't a scary environment, for those used to cities.
I'd say downtown Detroit has passed Cleveland, but Cleveland overall is still a better urban environment. STL seems to have a particularly grim set of challenges.