I know I'm a nimby, but I still love Shannon Park for a stadium. I live right across the water from Shannon Park. It would be an opportunity to make an very attractive, attention-getting contribution to the skyline view from Halifax. To me, the attractiveness is very contingent on ferry access. With two ferry docks it would be a beautiful ride from the peninsula/CP/Bedford. I love the idea of super high density residential surrounding it. I love hopping on the ferry to get to concerts at Alderney Landing. For me, taking the ferry from somewhere like Fairview Cove (with associated parking) would be super sweet. In fact, having a ferry connection/transit hub close to Burnside might not be a bad idea overall for Metro and relieve some problems with bridges.
I ALSO love the idea of garrison grounds for an ampitheatre. I wonder if we don't have good ampitheatres because our weather is so crappy? Anyway, anything that doesn't involve me sitting directly on a muddy hill to go to a concert is a huge plus and I think that site is criminally underused. And Halifax needs more live music venues IMO.