Regardless of my feeling on Queen's Marque (I like some things, don't like others, am very unimpressed with the centre block portion) Halifax's DRC is kinda...easy to impress.
|
It's not what I was expecting and I have some definite reservations, but it is also impressive in many ways, and it's growing on me as well.
This is not really the right attitude, but when I see views like the one in this video, my reaction is to think: I don't even care, just start building over those massive parking lots ASAP... https://www.facebook.com/flitelab/vi...7966685902781/ |
Quote:
...and get rid of the creepy floating humans in the 'public art' area (though I know that will not be as rendered)! :haha: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I think overall it's a beautiful proposal, but there are some things that could be changed. But it's an easy net-improvement to what is in the waterfront now, especially if they retain some space for existing kiosks in the plaza or just on the other side. |
I'm also liking this proposal more and more, especially the public-facing elements. This really creates a nice public space for people to sit, hang, lounge near the water.
|
(Repost from the Canada section.)
Construction prep is starting for Queen's Marque in Halifax and they are doing some interesting work to preserve marine habitat while the new structure is built. They're going to install some concrete blocks meant to act as artificial reefs. These will provide extra places for bottom dwelling plants and animals to live. They are adding the blocks because the building will extend into the water permanently, but also because they are going to use cofferdam construction for underground parking that will be below sea level. This means that for a while there will be a dam structure extending out from the waterfront and they will pump out the water so that they can work on dry land that used to be the harbour floor. Blocks: https://scontent-sea1-1.cdninstagram...68426511_n.jpg Here's the development (with residential portion highlighted in this rendering): https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CnqjTYhXgAAGemh.jpg:large Source |
Quote:
Apparently climate change and sea level rise combined with a major fall storm is of little concern to Armour Group and WDC. |
Quote:
Maybe it's just me, or maybe it's the fault of the artist who did these conceptions of the development, or maybe it's the design itself, but the look of this thing just has not impressed me from day one. It just seems bland and monolithic. |
Quote:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HlSpc87Jfr0 |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I think you can get away with a somewhat stark building like this if the quality of construction and materials is relatively good. That's what the developer is promising, and that's what a lot of existing MacKay Lyons-Sweetapple buildings are like (I have been hoping for a large, urban, non-institutional building from them for Halifax for a while). Hopefully the development lives up to that. Either way the style is not going to be for everybody but if the quality is good it will add some nice contrast. Aside from the design I think it's also filling a big hole in the city. To take one example, it looks like the space around Lower Water Street and the narrow lane beside the museum is going to "work" again once this building goes in. The space between buildings is more what the city would have been like before the waterfront demolitions of the 1950's-70's. http://media1.fdncms.com/thecoast/im...235/queen3.jpg (Looking at this image, the projection also seems different from what you would see in person. It's exaggerating the scale of the building and the open spaces; that is good if you want to make something look impressive and monumental but it's not going to appeal to those who prefer "human-scaled buildings".) |
Is the residential building literally called "The Bland"?
I like the starkness of that rendering. It has a very european look and interface with the area. I agree that if the materials are done well, it would be good. |
Quote:
|
I really do hope the design gets a revamp. I am not a lover of it. I think they can do much better for such a Marquee site......
|
Quote:
|
Will it be built when Cogswell is being torn down ? Seems sensible to wait until Cogswell is closed and Lower Water is free from 60 foot truck trailer combos.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Just wondering........... I always hated those trucks in the downtown core. They seemed so incongruous. |
And if I may offer my own personal opinion on the Queen's Marque project:
The massing on Lower water Street doesn't bother me, but I have serious misgivings about the harbor facing portion of the project. It just doesn't seem to blend in well with the ambience of the remainder of the harbor front, and to my mind breaks up the character of the boardwalk way too much. I think they can do better........... |
All times are GMT. The time now is 2:04 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.