The Official Moncton, NB Project Thread


And we're back!!!

default.jpg


Pretty easy to insert this image!

CBC article regarding the Subway Block:


Third floor needs to be sacrificed (I can live with that). Rear of the building has to be modified as well (moved further from the CNR track). Also not mission critical in terms of preserving the building. I am very pleased to see that this building will likely be saved. This will in fact preserve this entire downtown city block. This is very important since this block is the linchpin connecting the downtown east and west portions of Main Street.
I would be very happy to see this proposal move forward. Too much of Moncton's heritage has already disappeared.
 
A couple of years ago I came up with a whimsical plan for a possible LRT system in the greater Moncton area. This is not something that will happen imminently, but, as the city continues to grow, and develops more suburban growth nodes, I think such a system will ultimately become inevitable. Consider this a system for 25 years in the future or so.

I have altered the routings slightly from my previous proposal, and, I have divided the routing plan into three segments to reduce the "minification" that was present on the previous plan. This makes it easier to see what I am getting at.







I have proposed two lines - a red line and a green line. The red line is longer and would be the first one built. It would extend from YQM westward to Magnetic Hill, a distance of about 16 km or so. There would be 13 stops.

The stops would be:

1) - Magnetic Hill (Magic Mountain, Zoo)
2) - Casino (Casino NB, Molson Canadian Centre).
3) - Maplehurst (suburban commuter stop, Maplehurst Middle School)
4) - Evergreen (suburban commuter stop, Moncton North YMCA)
5) - MID (serves the industrial park)
6) - Franklin Yards (Centennial Park, Moncton Sportsplex)
7) - Highfield (downtown west including Avenir Centre)
8) - City Hall (downtown east)
9) - Champlain Place
10) - Acadie (downtown Dieppe)
11) - Thomas/Centrale (suburban commuter stop)
12) - Uptown Dieppe ( retail district around the Superstore & Coop/IGA)
13) - Airport

Such a route would be able to serve most of the major points of interest in the greater Moncton area. Most, but not all. This is why I have also proposed a green line as well. This line will be necessary as the Vision Lands builds out. It would be built as required, perhaps 30-40 years from now.

The stops would be:

1) - Magnetic Hill (Magic Mountain/Zoo)
2) - Crandall University
3) - Mapleton (northwest Vision Lands, retail/hotel cluster)
4) - Vision Lands (suburban town centre for the Vision Lands, Mapleton Centre)
5) - Universite Avenue (UdeM, Dumont Hospital, ASEC)
6) - Champlain Place.

The Green Line would be much shorter, but, would service the Vision Lands, which could have as many as 40-50,000 residents one day, as well as both universities, This line has the potential to be quite busy.

Some people might ask why there are so few stops. The reason is that this is an LRT system, not a street running tram (for the most part). The system would be designed to get people quickly to their destinations. Busses would run in the suburbs to get passengers to the LRT stations.

One of the advantages of the routing system I have proposed is that the routes for the most part run along existing greenways with very little street interaction. Where streets are crossed, there would be gates and signals. Where the LRT crosses a major arterial, grade separation would be necessary. The ONLY place where the LRT would be street running would be in the downtown from Vaughan Harvey Blvd to roughtly the Superstore. The LRT would follow a route along Gordon and Queen Streets. I chose this route because it is less congested than Main Street, but still gives excellent access to the city hall district and to the entertainment district around the Avenir Centre.

Still a very expensive proposition costing hundreds of millions of dollars. This is not something that a city of 200,000 people would normally consider, but, at some point in time, there might be 400,000 people in greater Moncton. We should be planning ahead and potentially protecting right of ways. If we don't we could regret it in the future. This is the problem in Halifax now. Halifax is 550,000 now and traffic congestion is out of control. Unfortunately, there is no easy way for them to develop an LRT system now as there are no feasible ROWs. I would hate to see that happen to Moncton.

Thoughts?
 
Regarding an LRT system for greater Moncton, there is an option for another crosstown connector line (lets' call it the yellow line).

It would run along the Wheeler Blvd and Findlay Blvd corridor from the Vision Lands to Findlay Park. It would provide interconnectivity with both the green and red lines, and would run between several important suburban town centres in the metro area. Again, by running along the Wheeler Blvd corridor, this would minimize street interactions. A fairly large portion of this line however would likely have to be elevated because of frequent interchanges along the Wheeler Blvd corridor.

Probable stations include:

1) - Vision Lands (suburban town centre, Mapleton Centre, transfer station to the Green Line)
2) - Trinity Drive (Wheeler Park Shopping Centre)
3) - Junction Yards (suburban town centre, routing of the line would be almost certainly along the west side of Wheeler therefore access would be via the planned Ryan St. pedestrian overpass)
4) - MID (industrial park north, transfer station to the Red Line).
5) - St. George (industrial park south)
6) - Salisbury Road (commuter station).
7) - Riverview Downtown (town hall)
8) - Findlay Park (suburban town centre)

The main reason for a north/south connector along this alignment is that it would connect three major suburban town centres (Vision Lands, Junction Yards, Findlay Park) that combined, could ultimately have a population of about 75,000 people. Major shopping centres would also be served and connections to both the red and green lines would improve the ability to commute across the metro area.

There could possibly be the potential for a fourth line along the Dieppe/Harrisville Blvd corridor. This really depends on how this corridor builds out. The ROW is generally wide enough for an LRT line if the demand justifies it.
 
Still a very expensive proposition costing hundreds of millions of dollars. This is not something that a city of 200,000 people would normally consider, but, at some point in time, there might be 400,000 people in greater Moncton. We should be planning ahead and potentially protecting right of ways. If we don't we could regret it in the future. This is the problem in Halifax now. Halifax is 550,000 now and traffic congestion is out of control. Unfortunately, there is no easy way for them to develop an LRT system now as there are no feasible ROWs. I would hate to see that happen to Moncton.
Every city should have a long-term transportation plan integrated with land use planning that follows a true high growth scenario 30-50 years into the future. It doesn't mean you prematurely build the infrastructure and in fact it dramatically reduces the cost of building in the future when done right. Halifax planning is poor with almost no leadership from council on any major issue and the province of NS doesn't invest in transit. The feds do invest, but tend to match municipal and provincial funding. This makes the Halifax/NS situation even dumber as so much money has been left on the table, while many people there think it's a wise money-saving approach. They are paying the same federal taxes whether they get the funding or not.
 
Every city should have a long-term transportation plan integrated with land use planning that follows a true high growth scenario 30-50 years into the future. It doesn't mean you prematurely build the infrastructure and in fact it dramatically reduces the cost of building in the future when done right. Halifax planning is poor with almost no leadership from council on any major issue and the province of NS doesn't invest in transit. The feds do invest, but tend to match municipal and provincial funding. This makes the Halifax/NS situation even dumber as so much money has been left on the table, while many people there think it's a wise money-saving approach. They are paying the same federal taxes whether they get the funding or not.
100%! And with infrastructure development for Vision Lands now moving forward, combined with the likely Shediac CA–CMA amalgamation, Greater Moncton could be well on its way toward 300,000+ residents by mid 2030s
 
Any regional transportation strategy should be multifactorial. In my discussion above, I have concentrated on LRT. Obviously LRT will not work in all circumstances. In particular, my proposal does not offer Moncton East very much, and, major corridors like Mountain Road and Champlain Street are ignored. This is because dedicated ROWs aren't really available in these areas. The best option for these areas is probably an enhanced bus service. If LRT is developed elsewhere in the city, then this enhanced bus service could be accomplished by a simple redeployment of resources.

In the downtown core of the city, including Main Street and Assumption Blvd, you could have a separate street running tram system using lighter vehicles than on the LRT system, Finally, on a more regional basis, heavy commuter rail could be brought into the mix. MonctonGoldenTriangle mentioned the eventual inclusion of Shediac into the Moncton CMA. There is a former railway ROW leading to Shediac. This could be recommissioned for a commuter rail service. Also, existing CNR trackage could be used for a heavy commuter rail service leading to Salisbury (or Petitcodiac) to the west and Sackville to the east.

Just imagine how fantastic it would be for students if all three regional universities (MTA, UdeM and Crandall) were easily accessible by public transit option. They would all benefit, particularly Mount Allison, since it is just far enough from the city that the daily drive back and forth borderlines on being impractical, especially in the wintertime.
 
Problem with Shediac is rail ROW stops stone cold at the Chesley-Breaux Bridge-Rte 15 ramps roundabout unless you want to get into a mess of eminent domain and road realignment. Too bad it can't get as far as the IGA on Main Street. Would be an ideal place to terminate, instead of, like, a park and ride at Lino/Riverside.
 
Problem with Shediac is rail ROW stops stone cold at the Chesley-Breaux Bridge-Rte 15 ramps roundabout unless you want to get into a mess of eminent domain and road realignment. Too bad it can't get as far as the IGA on Main Street. Would be an ideal place to terminate, instead of, like, a park and ride at Lino/Riverside
Indeed. These is no simple way to get to downtown Shediac any more. It is not too late however to reroute the final couple of km of a recommissioned rail line out to the Ohio Road and it could terminate in a station close to the proposed commercial development to be built there. A bus could complete the journey to downtown Shediac. A station out there would actually be fairly convenient to Parlee Beach too.
 
Moncton could get some rail transit without too much investment by piggy-backing off of regional rail. NS/NB should invest in consolidating a rail corridor using some portions of existing lines and some new sections (follow highways where that is feasible and build a YHZ spur, but use twinned sections in dedicated ROWs near the cities), and then the corridor could have a mix of trains serving different portions, like 2 trains a day each way for some commuters plus intercity combined with one extra train that does a couple extra trips within the respective commutersheds. If paired with land use planning you would have some extra suburban shops that would anchor new growth and over the long term increase ridership a lot. It would be a fabulous service that would get you to a lot of useful destinations and in the long run wouldn't cost very much.

If this plan started "now" it would be a plan for a Moncton metro area over 250,000 people with a bunch of added development concentrated near the up-zoned station areas, as it would take years before service would begin.
 


Back
Top