Canadian Transit Thread II


Took a trip to Alberta. Unfortunately didn't get a chance to ride the C-Train (other than the short fare-free section downtown on the last day for fun) but Edmonton's LRT is pretty great. Fast, smooth as butter and expansive compared to Ottawa and Calgary. The Valley Line is really a game changer. Seemed to have transit priority throughout, except maybe some parts of Valley, didn't ride t enough to know for sure.

This is compared to Ottawa which has very slow stretches and rides pretty rough throughout. That's not just because it's low floor since the Valley Line was smooth and fast. Capital Line though doesn't have level boarding, which was surprising.
 
The tunnel entrance is taking shape in the heart of Quebec City. Starting in mid-November, work on the René-Lévesque portal will reach a new milestone. This key piece of infrastructure will allow the tramway to transition from its surface-level route into the tunnel. The work will take place at the existing construction site on Boulevard René-Lévesque Est, between Avenue Turnbull and Rue de l’Amérique-Française.

https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61586616952277

917045171_122127618501220565_5914845273352964325_n.jpg


876399450_122125596813220565_5692087228657561402_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
The decision about where LRT needs to be above ground vs under ground is often ass backwards in Canada. When PT is the priority, you put it above ground in the city centre where passengers can see the places they want to go and pedestrians can see a train coming. On low density stroads with far less of interest, you tunnel. That so many Canadian municipalities do the opposite speaks to how car centric the culture still is. They design LRT with cars being the priority. Build it so cars can have the most space possible.

This car centric Doug Ford mindset is frustrating in a country trying to urbanize and build walkable people first cities: building rail to free up more space for cars instead of building rail to get people OUT of their cars. Toronto did the same dumb thing with the Eglinton Crosstown. Building LRT projects where quick easy car commutes shouldn't be the rationale.
 
Last edited:
The decision about where LRT needs to be above ground vs under ground is often ass backwards in Canada. When PT is the priority, you put it above ground in the city centre where passengers can see the places they want to go and pedestrians can see a train coming. On low density stroads with far less of interest, you tunnel. That so many Canadian municipalities do the opposite speaks to how car centric the culture still is. They design LRT with cars being the priority. Build it so cars can have the most space possible.

This car centric Doug Ford mindset is frustrating in a country trying to urbanize and build walkable people first cities: building rail to free up more space for cars instead of building rail to get people OUT of their cars. Toronto did the same dumb thing with the Eglinton Crosstown. Building LRT projects where quick easy car commutes shouldn't be the rationale.

I think there are a few fairly rare cases where that's an issue but in the overwhelming number of cases, urban rail goes underground in the city centre because it's faster and higher capacity rather than to preserve car space. It's true that space - for any purpose - is at a premium in a city centre, but even if the city centre was car-free, there would still be a high density of intersections and cross walks which limits frequency since even with signal priority, people would still need to cross the tracks even if just pedestrians, cyclists, and other transit vehicles. Plus, the size of some downtown blocks can limit train lengths since a train needs to be able to stop without blocking cross streets. Whereas in outer areas the intersections are more widely spaced and it's less likely to have two or more routes combined which means each corridor has lower frequency.

Fact is, most transit-oriented cities have some (sometimes a lot) of underground rail in the city center. LRT is not fundamentally different in that sense. It's just urban rail transit like subways with the added ability of street-running in locations where that makes sense which doesn't tend to apply to the city centre imo. It makes sense for streetcars and "trams" that function as more local transit but not a longer rapid transit line that needs to be faster. Especially when it runs through the city centre rather than just delivering people into downtown like a commuter rail. The Quebec city LRT would basically be the spine of its transit system the way an underground subway line is the spine of many transit systems. QC is just smaller and doesn't need the higher cost of heavy rail when it can save money on the sections outside the city centre.
 
Chapter 13: Concluding thoughts
22:43 So the ION LRT is definitely not perfect. I didn’t expect it to be. But it is genuinely frustrating how much better it is than the LRTs in Toronto,
22:52 Nevermind the crappy BRTs that have been built all over Ontario. Cities across Canada need to pay attention to what’s happening KW.
23:00 They should look at this LRT, And the great improvements around it, And they should say, let’s build something exactly like that.

 


Back
Top