Apparently the Cats space has just gotten worse and worse and worse and is now badly in need of repairs, which wouldn't have been required had it been occupied (and thus maintained) in the meantime. Or so I recall reading a while back.
Unfortunately it's just in a terrible location for food primary. It's a solid one to two blocks from even the edge of the tourist "blast zone" (lol) and it gets little sun in the afternoon. There is tons of traffic there in the form of parents bringing their kids to the splash pad or overseeing a birthday party for 6 year olds: a demographic that's not exactly raring to jump on the patio for happy hour beers and yam fries.
Yes, I'm surprised they don't turn it over to a cultural group or art gallery.