Winnipeg | Downtown | 138 Portage Ave | East Block Lofts | U/C


Despite all the dooming, I think Winnipeg's undergoing a more subtle type of growth that isn't flashy or exciting compared to, say, the projects you've listed above in Baghdad. As of September, residential building construction permits have totaled $1.5 billion over 4,344 permits so far for this year in Winnipeg, which is up 30% compared to the same time period in 2025. That's a lot of residential building.

The reason nobody feels like $1.5 billion to $2 billion worth of residential construction "isn't very exciting" is because that building is largely driven by multi-family residential all across the city, usually taking the form of 3 to 5 story groundscrapers either in denser greenfield or infill neighborhoods. This is boring, yet much needed growth. This type of growth is preferable to 4,500 single family homes built in suburbs and a single 30-story apartment tower being built downtown. Urbanists have wanted infill and a "denser" city for a long time, and over the past 15 years, we've been getting it. It just turns out that "increased density" in a prairie city takes the form of 20 or 30 groundscrapers scattered throughout mature and new neighborhoods, and not 2 or 3 30-story skyscrapers concentrated in downtown.

I know this is mostly a skyline forum, but we have to acknowledge that this type of boring growth we are seeing is important, and will set us up for good success in a few decades. As cheaper land in mature neighborhoods and on the fringes of Winnipeg get built up with new structures, soon the lowest hanging fruit cost-wise to developers will be eaten up. That will push up land prices while making mature neighborhoods more attractive and safe due to increased population, and make building closer to, or in, downtown will become more feasible as time goes on.

Sure, a war-torn middle eastern city may be seeing a small influx of shiny skyscrapers being built to accommodate a few rich international speculators who wish to see quick returns on an emerging post-war economy, but how much every-day run of the mill housing is being built that the average citizen can afford throughout the rest of their city?

When people are using words like “depressing”, “unappealing”, “brutally boring”, and “lack of effort” on this forum, I think this in reference to quality (both the quality of design and materials), not the height. It’s great that we are seeing so much development regardless of how many stories. But my guess is that folks are mostly disappointed with the quality of recent builds.

My silly example of Baghdad, which is experiencing a huge residential boom, was just to show that even in places you’d least expect are somehow getting higher quality builds in both design (which is somewhat subjective) and quality materials (no styrofoam, hardie board, etc.). Why that is, I don’t know.
 
I don’t find the new addition all that offensive, and I think it will look fine once the tyndall stone base is on. Overall, it’s a positive development, the Keewayden block is being restored, an empty lot is gone, and there will soon be more than 100 people living there.
 
When people are using words like “depressing”, “unappealing”, “brutally boring”, and “lack of effort” on this forum, I think this in reference to quality (both the quality of design and materials), not the height. It’s great that we are seeing so much development regardless of how many stories. But my guess is that folks are mostly disappointed with the quality of recent builds.

My silly example of Baghdad, which is experiencing a huge residential boom, was just to show that even in places you’d least expect are somehow getting higher quality builds in both design (which is somewhat subjective) and quality materials (no styrofoam, hardie board, etc.). Why that is, I don’t know.

A couple of reasons why this is:

1. Construction prices: building construction prices are probably up 30% or more post-COVID (compared to 2019), well above CPI inflation. Have rents risen fast enough to cover higher construction costs? Probably not. So, to make the numbers work, developers have to find a place to lower costs. I'm guessing flashy and expensive exterior materials along with nice design and aesthetics are among the first things to cut. They can't do too much cutting on interiors since, all else equal, people prefer to have a nicer interior over a nicer exterior if they have to choose one, and they also have to meet certain building codes for fire, safety, accessibility, and our cold climate. So exterior niceties are the first to go until rents catch up.

2. Buildings that are designed to attract millionaire/billionaire speculative investment are going to look a lot different than average, every day buildings built in a western city that have to turn a profit based on typical market rents.

The reality is that market rents in Winnipeg are below most other large Canadian cities, international investors don't want to speculate here, and our climate is harsh. So, to turn a profit, developers stick with basic materials without sacrificing interior quality.

Until such a time that construction costs come down and/or market rents rise, I'd anticipate most building in Winnipeg will look similar to what we've seen over the last few years. Is this exciting? Not really. Is it good that we can house the average renter in modern accommodations with full climate control, plumbing, parking, and interior amenities while meeting western standards for fire, safety and accessibility despite the outside not looking mind blowing? Absolutely.
 
I don’t find the new addition all that offensive, and I think it will look fine once the tyndall stone base is on. Overall, it’s a positive development, the Keewayden block is being restored, an empty lot is gone, and there will soon be more than 100 people living there.

Agreed. Visuals aside, it's a net positive for the area and bringing more cohesiveness between Portage + Main, The Exchange and Railside. If it spurs more development on the parking lots between Westbrook, Portage and Lombard, it will have served its purpose
 
Z1MP61y.jpeg
 


Back
Top