• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

What is Britain's second city?


Glasgow, Birmingham, and now Manchester have all claimed to be the UK’s 'Second City,' but Liverpool stands apart—a distinct identity underscored by fans recently booing the national anthem at the FA Cup Final.
 
I always used to think Birmingham was the ugly, soulless city for postwar cars and concrete, Manchester the one that held onto its history more:

Brum:

images
images


s.jpg



Manc:

e9a7dbb14448f08f749470a5c779e208.jpg
man.jpg


E7800879-Manchester_city_centre.jpg
s.webp




However, having recently revisited... and what a turnaround! Birmingham was full of beautiful civic spaces and its centre pedestrianised - completely reinvented:

BirminghamCommonwealthGames_210_1__d923ff56-95f6-4e1e-ad9a-47ffc6dad5e1.jpg


Birmingham-Jazz-Festival-Event_R.webp


s.jpg




While Manchester was a ghost of its former self - scruffy, dirty, and a barren streetscape undergoing a retail and nightlife apocalpyse, while filling with ugly skyscrapers. The constant soaking with rain didnt help:

0_Manchester-City-Centre-GVs.jpg


1ea9ed8f43d98d6e3735eaf246ed536d.jpg
s.jpg



The funky Northern Quarter no longer hits when the streets are empty:

NQ-feat.png


Same with the civic squares looking more and more abandoned

6PWQ_H.jpg


13c17e3ad2e1e2c9a090dd2f481e4507.jpg
 
Last edited:
By European standards, both cities rank as rather ugly to be honest. They don't rank anywhere on a list of places to visit for tourists. Britain was never very good at building beautiful cities, perhaps because people were more interested in making money than producing art. You can see it in the very cheap design of buildings built for rent, with their rectangle windows without ornament. And then things got worse with WW2 bombings and post-war urban planners' vandalism.
 
By European standards, both cities rank as rather ugly to be honest. They don't rank anywhere on a list of places to visit for tourists. Britain was never very good at building beautiful cities, perhaps because people were more interested in making money than producing art. You can see it in the very cheap design of buildings built for rent, with their rectangle windows without ornament. And then things got worse with WW2 bombings and post-war urban planners' vandalism.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder sir
 
By European standards, both cities rank as rather ugly to be honest. They don't rank anywhere on a list of places to visit for tourists. Britain was never very good at building beautiful cities, perhaps because people were more interested in making money than producing art. You can see it in the very cheap design of buildings built for rent, with their rectangle windows without ornament. And then things got worse with WW2 bombings and post-war urban planners' vandalism.

To be fair, cities in Europe have always been a little more ugly than what they are romanticized to be. And in general, cities in Europe get uglier as you go north.
 
Some pics of old Manchester before the war. Notorious for industry and terraced slums, but its centre was a showcase, a grand mercantile nexus touted as the 'second city of empire' alongside Birmingham and Glasgow, that was a magnet for bombing, then the postwar developers after.

Beautiful cities:

manc.jpg
1ce03609da92f411558027a3544a30d4.jpg



s.jpg
images


oldtownhall2.jpg
M-0039.jpg


images
manc.jpg


manc.avif
images


exchangebuilding.jpg
Assize-Courts.jpg



images
images




A typical surviving street:

6E5Y_H.jpg
 
Last edited:
Similarly Birmingham -the sheer intricacy of the buildings and streetwalls would have made it one of the world's most beautiful cities if they'd survived:

0_TRMRMMGLPICT000020584192.jpg


s.jpg
b.jpg



b.jpg
x.jpg
b.jpg


b.jpg
birmingham-corporation-street-1896_37269_large.jpg


GettyImages-464001687.jpg
s.jpg


s.webp
b.jpg


Survivor street, at what the centre could have looked like:

corporation-street-birmingham-west-midlands-england-uk-G2W3NE.jpg
 
Last edited:
Hitlers Baedeker Raids targeted Britain's most beautiful cities - so-called due to Baedeker guidebooks that were used to sort them:

AL18g_SbfpATRLYI9eR2_Ad0nfYGgWCrHfoNz1DjwPjuicoRfoo1xSbcUzsLD8G3ljQo6HNTjZArgqI=s1200



blog-york-bombed-st-martin-le-grand-bb9003806.jpg
images




TELEMMGLPICT000294207824_trans_NvBQzQNjv4BqfLyDFr-8aZAlztTUDugqWjWWYCUJcDr5Ty9BsWXPC1I.jpeg
canterbury-under-fire---damage-sustained-by-440nw-9830426a.jpg




Though thankfully many were rebuilt and the historicism repaired- you wouldn't tell otherwise anything had happened and the streets retain their feel:


Bath:

s.jpg



ss.webp
ss.webp
s.jpg



Canterbury:

s.avif



s.jpg
images





York:

an-aerial-photo-of-york-city-centre-the-minster-and-the-river-ouse-north-yorkshire-northern-england-uk-RB9PPR.jpg



s.jpg


s.webp
s.jpg



Norwich

63f6465945e79f5d6f55aa1a_norwich-aerial-photo-rs.webp
s.jpg


s.jpg
images
 
Last edited:
And in general, cities in Europe get uglier as you go north.
Last year while visiting Denmark I found Danish cities more beautiful than British cities. German cities were also quite nice before WW2 (if only a little repetitive with the same Wilhelmian architecture everywhere).
 
Hitlers Baedeker Raids targeted Britain's most beautiful cities - so-called due to Baedeker guidebooks that were used to sort them:

AL18g_SbfpATRLYI9eR2_Ad0nfYGgWCrHfoNz1DjwPjuicoRfoo1xSbcUzsLD8G3ljQo6HNTjZArgqI=s1200



blog-york-bombed-st-martin-le-grand-bb9003806.jpg
images
WW2 bombings are part of the reason, but they are far from the only reason.

After all, French cities were also abundantly bombed during WW2. Here for instance Orléans, terror bombed by the Germans in June 1940 with no military objective other than terrorizing the French population. Yet Orléans today is infinitely more beautiful than any British city.

Orleans1941.jpg


Orleans.jpg


Orleans1941-2.jpg


And today, partly rebuilt, party spared by the bombs.

Martroi-17.jpg


les-villes-qui-attirent-le-plus-les-acheteurs-immobiliers-region-par-region.jpg


For example here, after the 1940 German bombings:

Orleans1941-1.jpg


And now:

Martroi.png


I think one of the big reasons that explains why the British cities don't have that beauty and charm of continental cities is because the largest British cities like Manchester and Birmingham were mere villages before the Industrial Revolution, so they lack the depth and history of most continental cities.

A city like Orléans, for instance, was a large European city since Roman times, and you can still feel it, because its city center is very large, very ancient despite bombings. Birmingham and Manchester were mere villages when Orléans was one of Europe's largest cities, and they only passed Orléans in size in the 2nd half of the 18th century.

I was in Orléans one evening last year, and it's still a pleasure to walk in the Medieval streets that have been spared by the bombs, and see things that our ancestors could already see 500 years ago.

Some pictures I took during our nightly walk:

Orleans-V1.jpg


Orleans-V2.jpg


Orleans-V3.jpg


Orleans-V2.jpg
 
This was the population of provincial British cities (urban areas) in 1806 (mid-point between 1801 and 1811 censuses), all cities above 35,000 inh.:
- Manchester: 99,800
- Edinburgh: 92,200
- Liverpool: 89,400
- Glasgow: 88,300
- Birmingham: 79,500
- Bristol: 69,700
- Leeds: 57,700
- Plymouth: 49,200
- Norwich: 37,000
- Portsmouth: 36,700

For comparison, population of provincial French cities at the 1806 census, all cities above 35,000 inh.:
- Lyon: 114,600
- Marseille: 99,200
- Bordeaux: 94,200
- Rouen: 86,700 (but more than 100,000 in its urban area)
- Nantes: 80,400
- Lille: 71,100
- Toulouse: 51,700
- Strasbourg: 51,500
- Orléans: 42,700
- Metz: 41,600
- Nîmes: 41,200
- Amiens: 39,900
- Caen: 36,500

And all the US cities with more than 35,000 inhabitants in 1806:
- New York City: 80,000
- Philadelphia: 48,300
- Baltimore: 37,200

Canada: none (the largest city in 1806, Montréal, had ca. 27,500 inhabitants).
 
This was the population of provincial British cities (urban areas) in 1806 (mid-point between 1801 and 1811 censuses), all cities above 35,000 inh.:
- Manchester: 99,800
- Edinburgh: 92,200
- Liverpool: 89,400
- Glasgow: 88,300
- Birmingham: 79,500
- Bristol: 69,700
- Leeds: 57,700
- Plymouth: 49,200
- Norwich: 37,000
- Portsmouth: 36,700
Why 1806?

For comparison, population of provincial French cities at the 1806 census, all cities above 35,000 inh.:

How is that relevant in a thread about Britain's second city?
 
I think it's relevant because it attracts someone pathologically unable to stop himself putting others down, and introducing France La Formidable (always does it better as long as you keep changing the parameters). In conversations say about my cat, or uranus or cars -so here we are, listening ad nauseum to The Great Knowledge Of All Things as his opinion is FACT.

Talk about the UNESCO Heritage sites of Ecuador and someone will wave their hand - look back in 1953 we had more flower baskets, while your economy is pathetic! And anyway nothing compares to ORLEANS.

Yes, 1806, France, Orleans and its 1806 population, I've been having so many sleepless nights about these subjects, France, Orleans. 1806.
 
Last edited:
I've been wondering why is Orleans so called? Does it mean something? I always thought it was a name.

What was the population of Bourges in 1789, compared to Norwich?

Ohhhh how I wish I was French, and being so great and glorieuses, while I wallow in my ugly cities, bad food and immigrant-powered fall of civilisation. If only my crying pillow was a croissant, like one of the real ones with real BUTTER (won many awards, not a single dark hand was involved, the world knows this which is why it's everywhere).
 
Last edited:
:haha:
I've been wondering why is Orleans so called? Does it mean something? I always thought it was a name.

What was the population of Bourges in 1789, compared to Norwich?

Ohhhh how I wish I was French, and being so great and glorieuses, while I wallow in my ugly cities, bad food and immigrant-powered fall of civilisation. If only my crying pillow was a croissant, like one of the real ones with real BUTTER (won many awards, not a single dark hand was involved, the world knows this which is why it's everywhere).

:haha::haha::haha:
 
The only stupid people I see in this thread are those who prefer to use sarcasm rather than reasoning. This is a place to learn things. If you don't want to learn things, move to Tiktok.
 
The only stupid people I see in this thread are those who prefer to use sarcasm rather than reasoning. This is a place to learn things. If you don't want to learn things, move to Tiktok.

Homer, if you don't want to be questioned every time you intentionally divert an unrelated thread into a discussion about France, then go back to SSC. Oh, that's right--you can't. They banned you because you are a troll.
 
I posted there no later than yesterday. But try again. :haha:

People preferring to "shoot the messenger" rather than addressing the actual message because they can't stand being contradicted always makes me laugh.
 


Back
Top