Note: I think the links should be working now. Sorry for any inconvenience!
Actually the reverse would have been true. Instead of looking out of place it would have made an enormous positive impact on the Downtown Dallas skyline.
And it would have pulled more development towards it, so over time there would be various large skyscrapers surrounding it.
I did a quick cut and paste of a picture of the Griffin Square Hotel that was proposed for the site (60 stories at 913 feet tall, which is only eight feet shorter than the BofA Tower). It is easy to scale because it would be essentially the same height as the BofA building. I took various images of Downtown Dallas and pasted the image into it to show what Downtown would have roughly looked like from differing angles with a spectacular 913 foot tall hotel on that spot.
The next to last image below is an actual image of the current Omni Hotel under construction with the 913 foot tall structure superimposed over where the Omni is located in the image, which is about as precise as one can get.
Now tell me which building looks better on our skyline????
Until Dallas gets away from the "short, fat, squat" mindset for its Downtown buildings we will never become the metropolis that we should be - we are the 4th largest metro in the nation behind New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago. We just have to build Downtown and near Downtown buildings that look like we belong in that league!
Dallas does have many very nice skyscrapers that are big city league - don't get me wrong - but so many others instead of being the soaring skyscrapers that they easily could have been are instead "short, fat, squat" buildings - One Arts Plaza immediately comes to mind as well as the Omni Hotel.
Sleek and captivating designs that are more big city in their presence and presentation are Museum Tower (under construction), 1900 Pacific (proposed) and Victory Tower/Mandarin Oriental Hotel (on hold). The Hall Arts District Tower renderings seem to suggest it will fit into the mold of big city design and construction, so we'll keep our fingers crossed there.
We need more of those style buildings and less of the squat 25 story buildings, especially when two or three get built of that same general height and design! Build one sleek and tall 50, 60 or 75 story building instead! In fill of 25-35 story buildings is already in place in a large area of Downtown, Uptown and Victory Park, now the taller structures need to fill in the skyline.
Then replace most of the remaining parking lots with parks similar to what has occurred with Main Street Park, is occurring with Woodall Rogers Urban Park and Belo Park, and is planned for Pacific Park.
I just think Dallas missed the boat on this opportunity because with the City going ahead and building the convention hotel and it costing
half a billion dollars, something more for the money could have been had than the current Omni Hotel design. An incredibly missed opportunity indeed!