I never knew that before! I always assumed that the shopping mall idea was dropped with the rooftop hotel.
I can only guess why it wasn't successful. I imagine people did not like the idea of paying for parking at a mall when they could park at The Village or the Avalon Mall for free. Lack of density in the immediate area probably would have been another factor in the unsuccessfulness of it.
A downtown shopping complex would probably be much more successful if we built up density in the downtown core. We are getting a good start on that it with projects like MIX, Henry Bell and Star of the Sea, but hopefully in the coming years we continue to build up density in the downtown core.
Maybe sometime in the future, someone else will give a shopping complex a try
Thanks for sharing, and sorry for being so ill-knowledged!