Posted Dec 1, 2006, 11:06 PM
|
|
NEW YORK | CHICAGO
|
|
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: NYC
Posts: 3,532
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nowhereman1280
1. No matter how much you want it to be built in the South Loop, 3 miles out of downtown, or anywhere else thats more than a few blocks from Michigan Ave, Navy Pier, the Water Tower, or any other major tourist draw, it will not happen. Everyone keeps ignoring the fact that this is not just an antenna, its a tourist attraction that doubles as an antenna. No one wants to drive 3 miles out of downtown just to go to a slightly higher observatory when they can just go to the Hancock or the Sears and get roughly the same experience.
|
Three miles outside of downtown is too far, that doesnt mean it has to go right in the front of the city. I'd much prefer it set back farther. Besides, you'll get better views of the city if its not smack dab in the center.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nowhereman1280
2. There is a reason he is not just building a building like Miglin-Beitler or 7SD. Its because he thinks (whether correctly or not) that there will not be enough demand to support another building of that size. However, he may be able to convince investors that they can make a lot of money on this thing if they are willing to keep their money locked up in in for a decade while the hundreds of thosands of $25 skydeck tickets pour in, the resturant sells food at tourist prices, and the TV stations have to renewn multi million dollar leases multiple times.
|
Yeah, but 7SD is a better proposal. Not better economically? Sure. However, I really loathe broadcast towers. Its what makes tall buildings even more elegant. They're both economical and big.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nowhereman1280
3. No, the skyneedle is not the best building ever, it is second best after the Illinois. I'm telling you, thats what Beitler should be proposing, he should by the rights to that sketch and four squre blocks in the west loop, you know where the NIMBYs run rampant and prevent anything over 10 stories from being built, and build the Illinois there, just to teach the NIMBYS a lesson. Think of how much TV companies would be willing to pay for space that broadcasts not only to Chicago, but Milwaukee, Madison, Gary, Peoria, and possibly even Indianapolis. Haha, that would be sooo sweet, it would be like 4 times the height of the Sears. Then we could tell Dubai (and everyone else) to suck it.
|
Cant even think about arguing. Nowhereman for mayor.
|