Homicide stats in Canadian Cities

[BlackDog204]

Originally Posted by theman23

Not sure how accurate that is. Quebec and NFLD should probably swap colours and BC should be the same colour as Alberta.

It's completely inaccurate.

The map would give one the idea that Yukon is the deadliest province/territory (untrue), and that Nunavut is relatively tame (not true). Manitoba is the province with the highest homicide rate, but on the map, they label Saskatchewan as the color of the highest.

[Acajack]

Originally Posted by theman23

Not sure how accurate that is. Quebec and NFLD should probably swap colours and BC should be the same colour as Alberta.

I don't know what year the stats are from. Some recent years NL has been higher than QC.

[BlackDog204]

Originally Posted by Acajack

I don't know what year the stats are from. Some recent years NL has been higher than QC.

Doing colours on a chart for one single year, is impractical. Places like the Territories and PEI have too few people to make an accurate sample size. It must be done over multiple years.

An example would be Nova Scotia's 2020 per-capita murder rate. It's much higher than any other year due to the worst massacre in Canadian history. Excluding the massacre, the murder rate is relatively low in the province.

The same goes for places like Yukon and Nunavut. If one man kills his family of 5, then himself one year, it would spike the per-capita murder rate up, considering there are less than 45,000 people in each territory.

A ten year average gives a more accurate reading.

[JuelzJones]

Toronto - 18
Winnipeg - 10
Edmonton - 9
Montreal - 8
Ottawa - 7
Calgary 3
Vancouver - 1

[harls]

Originally Posted by JuelzJones

Ottawa - 7

6 of them by one guy.

[Luisito]

Originally Posted by harls

6 of them by one guy.

Has anything been said about what the motives behind that masscre were?

[kwoldtimer]

Originally Posted by Luisito

Has anything been said about what the motives behind that masscre were?

One is unlikely to hear anything official before the trial.

[kwoldtimer]

Fatal shooting, apparently targetted, Kitchener suburbs last night.

[Acajack]

Originally Posted by kwoldtimer

One is unlikely to hear anything official before the trial.

Mental health issues I am almost positive. Sure perhaps there was a dispute over rent or something else as he was a tenant in the family's home.

Still, who kills six people like that including little babies if they're in their right mind?

[ssiguy]

Originally Posted by JuelzJones

Toronto - 18
Winnipeg - 10
Edmonton - 9
Montreal - 8
Ottawa - 7
Calgary 3
Vancouver - 1

I appreciate the stats but I don't think they represent what is going on in the real world. Some cities take in the vast majority of the Metros like Calgary while some a very small amount like Victoria hence you don't get a true reflection of the murder rate of the "cities" due to potentially not including higher murder rate areas which are often in lower income suburbs. Victoria is a safe city but it can go years without a murder but that is due to the city itself being very wealthy and only having a population of 90,000. Nearly all the murders in Greater Victoria are outside the city itself.

I think a better metric is stats for the metropolitan area.

[kwoldtimer]

Originally Posted by Acajack

Mental health issues I am almost positive. Sure perhaps there was a dispute over rent or something else as he was a tenant in the family's home.

Still, who kills six people like that including little babies if they're in their right mind?

Arguably, most people who knowingly and gratuitously take a life have mental health issues but in most cases they remain criminally liable.

[Luisito]

Originally Posted by ssiguy

I appreciate the stats but I don't think they represent what is going on in the real world. Some cities take in the vast majority of the Metros like Calgary while some a very small amount like Victoria hence you don't get a true reflection of the murder rate of the "cities" due to potentially not including higher murder rate areas which are often in lower income suburbs. Victoria is a safe city but it can go years without a murder but that is due to the city itself being very wealthy and only having a population of 90,000. Nearly all the murders in Greater Victoria are outside the city itself.

I think a better metric is stats for the metropolitan area.

Fair point. I agree with you.

In the case of WInnipeg, all the homicides are concentrated in a couple of inner city areas making them some of the most dangerous areas in the country.

[kwoldtimer]

52 year old man shot and killed yesterday in Manor Park neighbourhood of Ottawa in what police describe as a targeted shooting. The location is directly across the street from Rockcliffe Park.

[JonHiseler]

Halifax just had its 3rd homicide of the year this afternoon. A teenage boy was stabbed in the parkade of the Halifax Shopping Centre.

[begratto]

Quebec as a whole (population : 9M) is at 22 so far this year :


Montreal GMA total (pop 4.5M) : 17
* Island of Montreal (pop 2.0M) : 8
* Montreal suburbs off-island (pop 2.5M) : 9
Quebec City (pop 0.8M) : 2
Elsewhere in Quebec (pop 3.7M) : 3

[SKvKREW]

3 more for Toronto today. All separate incidents.

[ssiguy]

The metros of both London & Windsor have yet to record their very first but the thing that really surprises me is that neither has Regina. Regina and Sask in general tend to have, with Manitoba, the highest murder rates in the country.

[manny_santos]

White Rock has had two random stabbings around the Pier in the past week or so. The victim in the first attack survived but the second victim did not. It appears both stabbings may have been committed by the same individual as the suspect descriptions are very similar.

[YOWetal]

Originally Posted by kwoldtimer

Arguably, most people who knowingly and gratuitously take a life have mental health issues but in most cases they remain criminally liable.

Lots of murders are business related and arguably rational
Alcohol is a big factor in domestic murders which I don't think qualifies as a mental illness.