Quote:
Originally Posted by Xtoval
Funny how a comment can be picked apart on this forum!
I think an important thing we can do for urban redevelopment is to liberalize our liquor laws. The problem is that you can't have free standing bars, except for cabarets, which must provide entertainment, or private clubs. You just can't have a small corner bar serving booze. It's illegal.
Ontario and BC allow free-standing bars, that is all I was saying. Plus having lived in Toronto for a long time, there is no doubt in my mind its bar scene is incomparably better than Winnipeg's. Not because it is a bigger city but because imaginative, creative people can afford to open bars.
The original rationale of Manitoba's laws was to close down the Main Street pool hall/bars that attracted young men fresh off the train and to prop up rural hotels during the slow season, by giving hotels the monopoly on beer sales and beverage rooms.
Why do you think Canad Inn bars survive? Because our antiquated liquor laws hold them up as the ideal. The hotel lobby fights like hell to prevent changes in the regulations. The NDP won't touch the unionized MLCC.
I am in Winnipeg a lot and walk around and think some entrepreneur should open up a bar in some old building full of character, as they would in nearly any other North American or European city I've visited. But then I remember Manitoba liquor laws make that impossible.
|
You're right that our liquor laws are stupid. Absolutely right.
But you make it sound like Winnipeg doesn't even have bars. There are three classes of liquor license, if I remember correctly: cabarets, lounges, and private clubs. I think the hotel thing you're thinking of has to do with off-license sales, which is behind Manitoba's silly convention of only having beer stores in hotels. But it's pretty easy to get around the other three. Lounges sell food. The Woodbine sells Michelinas that they throw in a microwave for you. Legions are all private clubs where you go through the minor inconvenience of signing in and not wearing a hat.
Anyway, I still pretty much agree with you. I've never lived in Toronto, but on my visits I've never been blown away by the bar scene. Some places are pretty good, but I've never longed for Toronto bars when I can spend a night drinking my way through the King's Head, The Duke of Kent, the Woodbine, and the Yellow Dog, or The Toad, Agit, and the River Legion.