Quote:
Originally Posted by smArTaLlone
|
Not a fan of what's happened to Avondale... or the concept of "transit oriented development" in general... it's an upside-down concept. It should be the other way around, transit orienting around development. A good question to ask might be, "would this development still fit here if it wasn't located next to a transit stop?"
The new development really throws off the scale of the village there. The empty lots were truly awful, but I think everybody got on the bandwagon too quickly with the TOD idea. It hasn't panned out to be what I thought it would be (I was in favor of it too before it was built).
In retrospect, it would have been much better to limit development to 2 or 3 stories, and do as much as possible to break up the lots into smaller pieces, as well as categorically excluding parking decks. And it wouldn't necessarily have to come at the cost of density-- may I remind everyone that Tokyo is one of the densest cities in the world and is mostly 3 story buildings. Density can be accomplished with narower streets and smaller lot sizes.
I think this is a consequence of "bird's eye planning" and will probably become something that will be criticized in the future in reference to 2010s development. With the advent of GIS and Google Maps, we saw things from above in a totally different way, but it led to SIMS style development that completely neglected the real world experiences of people who live in these places. We need to do better in the 2020s.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Street Advocate
I consider it a win we are now critiquing design out in Chamblee!
Really excited Chamblee continues to grow. Puts more MARTA accessible, walkable anchor points around the metro. Would love to see more infill come to East Point, too. Great area with a fair amount of industrial nearby that could be redeveloped.
|
I live in East Point... and I am glad our city council is kicking this stuff to the curb. We don't want it. Y'all have gotten so pie in the sky about running the numbers up (population density, etc.) that you don't see how these projects are ruining the city. Y'all gotta get from behind your screens and spend more time on the ground.