Interesting and thoughtful post. My thoughts to your points:
Quote:
Originally Posted by wave46
How do I think Canada will be in 2050, whatever its population? Worse, to be honest. Much worse, if we don't play our cards right.
Which is really depressing and where I hope I'm wrong.
But, there's a 'unhealthy' vibe to the economic growth last decade in several senses. It's not unlike the difference between eating a bag of potato chips for dinner and a well rounded meal for dinner. Yeah, both leave you full, but you feel much better after the latter instead of the former.
My concerns (in no particular order)
1. A continued trend towards deindustrialization and an over-reliance on housing price growth to make us feel wealthy. We don't make things here anymore competitively, we buy them using our exported unprocessed raw materials. Which is finite. The housing price growth isn't sustainable either - I don't see how prices can go up 5%+ per year forever. We're just bleeding the younger generation in a most insidious fashion by saddling them with huge debts.
|
Agreed. I've been concerned about this for a couple of decades as I've watched corporations shut down their Canada/US manufacturing facilities in favour of cheap/unregulated factories overseas. While there is a short-term benefit of increased profit going to the head offices of these companies, and cheap material goods for the rest of us, the countries suffer with loss of employment and loss of industrial capability.
Also, housing should just be that - an
affordable place to live and not a way to 'boost' our economy. I look at housing price growth as a negative, not a positive.
Quote:
2. Governments that can't stop deficit spending while the biggest liabilities (i.e. our aging population) swell. Healthcare and low taxes are great, but it's just an endless maw of cash. Which is great for the 90-year old who gets all the best care, but not exactly sustainable in the long-term. I don't know how we culturally have a conversation about death, but I fear that the Boomers' fear of death and disdain for being taxed will bleed the country dry.
|
While I agree that our government needs to be more careful about deficit spending, if I am interpreting your comments about Boomers/seniors/lifespan correctly, it is a little disturbing to me. What do you mean by that? Are you suggesting that younger generations don't fear death? Are you suggesting that only 'Boomers' want lower taxes? Do you not want healthcare for everybody? Do you not think that older generations who have worked hard all of their lives deserve to have dignity in their senior years? Sorry, but it just sounds like it's leaning towards the typical 'Boomer' bashing that appears to be popular today... correct me if I'm wrong (and I hope I am).
Another point I want to make is the proverbial '90-year-old who gets all the best care'. I can say from personal experience of helping the elderly that they do not receive the 'best care'. Especially those who do not have a younger person to advocate for them. Most times they receive the minimum of care to keep them alive, but that's it... and sometimes they don't even get that much. Oftentimes they will be turned away from emergency care as it appears to be felt among the medical community that they do not deserve the care since they are near the end of their lifespan. I often think how easy it is for people to make decisions like that when they don't have any personal investment, but be sure that when it is you or someone you care for, you will not have the same opinion.
Quote:
3. A shift in power to nations that don't even really have the pretense of wanting to be about human rights. If you think China is pushy now, wait until its economy doubles in size again. The current leader of the world faces many of the same problems we do here and seems to be even more disinclined to address them. The little spats we have with China now are more likely to hurt much more as they grow stronger and the US becomes more inwardly focused.
|
I agree that it's a concern, which also reflects on my comments to point (1).
Quote:
4. A lack of leadership. The leadership of 2020 hasn't exactly inspired me, especially in the English-speaking world. Leadership sometimes means making the hard choices - short-term pain for long-term gain. But we get Trump, BoJo and Mr. Blackface. It's hard to evoke Churchill, Kennedy, Pearson or Eisenhower in the current crop of 'leaders'. More like a squad of buffoons.
|
I agree that we appear to be suffering for actual leadership, but you have to be careful to not focus on the past too much through rose coloured glasses. Leaders of the past have been less than ideal and have made grave errors in judgement. What concerns me the most with the current crop of leaders is that they appear to be more autonomous these days, wanting to run countries like companies that adhere to their personal values and opinions. The decorum of respect and procedure seems to have gone out the window and we are left with justifications and denial (i.e. 'fake news').
I'm hoping that it will continue to be cyclical, as it has been in the past.
Quote:
5. The other billions. In 2050, the world's population is projected to be 9.7 billion. We're having problems now and we're going to add a couple more billion people to this planet? It's trying to bring a family of 7 out of poverty and they're thinking of having another 3 kids.
|
This is my main concern and has been for a long time. We can do all we can to fight climate change, but hugely increasing the population is only going to create more strain on our resources and our environment. I don't really understand why our economies appear to be designed to only work if your population continues to increase.
That said, I don't see any practical way to stabilize population growth as there are so many religious/cultural/personal/political motivations behind this growth, and there doesn't appear to be any will to do anything about it.
Quote:
I'm not at the point of losing faith yet, but my faith in the future of Canada (and the West) is being sorely tested these last few years. I feel we are making the politically expedient choices as opposed to the right ones. Which makes me start thinking about how mostly to protect myself while the world burns. I might just live long enough to end up being stuck with the bill for our poor decisions.
Which is really shitty. I've watched a few of JFK's speeches and almost am nostalgic (I'm not sure if it's nostalgia if I wasn't alive at the time) for the optimism of that era.
God, I hope I'm wrong.
|
My advice would be to try to take the positive outlook, though admittedly it has become more difficult to do so. If you look through history, political trends are usually cyclical, though unfortunately things have often gone off the rails before they are corrected - but there always seems to be a will to improve and rebuild when things go bad.
JFK's speeches came along at a particular point in history, and likely would have fallen on deaf ears in other eras. There has been some regression since those days, but there has also been progress as well - I think in JFK's days the idea of having an African-American president would not have even been considered. However now, since Obama has been replaced by Trump, I would consider the US (and much of the rest of the world) to be in the midst of another regression, but am hoping the world will bounce back again... but likely not before much more pain and angst is experienced.
Please note that the above are only my opinions... feel free to disagree as I always welcome constructive conversation.