Quote:
Originally Posted by ILNY
NYguy asked for examples, but it's not about what the park has but rather what it lacks and that is quality finishing. Instead of building ridiculously expensive $75 million Hudson Yards sculpture they could spend most of that money to bump up the park.
Lamp from River Park West.
Tree from WTC Park
|
What you see from the park is not the completed park. There are other features which as of now are not visible that will complete the picture. All you have now (visible) are trees and benches.
As far as the lamps on the river, that's ok for that location. The WTC memorial is different altogether. But as a whole, neither would qualify as the "New York" experience, and neither example would fly here. There was no need to reinvent the wheel here. If people want a New York that doesn't
look like New York, the world is full of places. They're creating a new neighborhood here, and there will be lots of "new". But should the street lights be different from the rest of the city? The crosswalks? How about the street signs? For that matter, why not create more superblocks instead of continuing with the Manhattan grid? That way we can have a "different" or "new" approach to design on the west side, if we're doing it for just that sake.
Me, I prefer New York as New York. And I'm glad Related is paying for that large sculpture, whatever the design may be. It's continuing a tradition of art work in public spaces with New York's major developments (think Rockefeller Center) that will further enhance the area. The area will be accessed through High Line park, itself a very innovative place, even if its not the first of its kind. But yeah, for Hudson River Park & Blvd, New York, please.
December 29, 2014