Quote:
Originally Posted by MacLac
Huh?! 19 goals (Neal) VS. 4 (Luc.) = HUGE win for the Oil. Smith (9 wins) vs Talbot (5 wins) = another Win for the Oil......
|
Talbot's lower win total than Smith's is highly misleading. Most of Talbot's losses haven't been on him (he's been very solid all season). The same most definitely can't be said of Smith, who's letting in at least as many softies this year as he did at his worst last year.
If you can honestly say you'd prefer to have Smith (3.03GAA, .897 Sv%) in the nets over Talbot (2.62GAA, .917 Sv%) this season then you've got some pretty thick homer glasses on. The Hockey News just gave Smith an F in their recent grading of off season free agent signings, so there's also that.
As for Neal versus Lucic, you can keep Neal's lazy, disinterested play (-21 as opposed to Looch's -2), and if you look at total points (27 for Neal, 10 for Lucic) and the fact that Lucic actually contributes even when he's not on the scoreboard I think I know which player I'd prefer to have on my team. We'll also thankfully take the draft pick that we'll get from you guys based on the goal differential between Neal and Lucic.