Quote:
Originally Posted by SimpleEng
Hi,
Just curious if anyone knows why Porter picked EWR for their New York City flights as opposed to JFK or LGA?
Wouldn't JFK be a better choice given the following? - JFK is a JetBlue hub, an existing Porter partner
- JFK is a better option for the majority of folks visiting NYC. Taxis from JFK to Manhattan are about half the price as EWR due to high tolls to get between NJ and NYC. JFK is also closer to Manhattan and has a subway stop via the AirTrain
- American and Delta have hubs in JFK setting Porter up nicely for future partnership with either
I assume the decision is cost related? Slots more expensive or not available at JFK?
Thanks
|
Slots is part of the answer why they chose EWR, that's for sure.
JFK is a level 3 slot controlled airport. EWR isn't. It's only a level 2. So easier access at EWR.
But there are other factors.
YTZ-EWR is a shorter flight, or at least should be. Flying all the way to JFK can add a hundred miles to your flight distance on some days. Simply go on FR24 and look at all the arrivals into JFK, especially those arriving from the west. They pass JFK and go over the ocean and then come back around to land. Very very inefficient, but a necessity, due to the proximity of EWR and LGA, two other very busy airports.
So all else being equal, If you're coming from the west, flying to EWR
usually cuts down on cost, and improves yield significantly compared to flying to JFK.
This being said, you can get vectored around significantly at EWR as well. That's why the schedules in/out of the NY3 airports are well padded. AC's block times on YYZ-EWR are actually higher than YYZ-JFK. Go figure.
As for lack of partners at EWR, you have to remember than YTZ-New York for PD is all about O&D and Canadian connections. They don't need connections on the NY end. So flying to JFK from YTZ is not important at all. EWR gets the job done.
And I've commuted from both EWR and JFK to Manhattan. EWR is just as convenient as JFK, to be honest. I don't remember thinking "JFK was so much easier". You take the Airtrain to the airport station and then NJ transit gets you to Penn Station in no time.
And btw, EWR is just as close to Manhattan as JFK. Both of them are around 16-17 miles from Manhattan. Since commuting from EWR involves a train, and not the subway, it's actually faster to get to Manhattan than via JFK.