Quote:
Originally Posted by WhipperSnapper
|
I don't see anything awesome about the existing East Harbour site other than its redevelopment potential but I agree that the surrounding residential areas (at least those north of Eastern Ave.) look fairly pleasant and quaint. Not sure about "awesome" since the residential streets in the immediate vicinity seem fairly typical of the old city but that's just me. But more importantly, I don't judge the merits of new development strictly by what it adds to an existing neighbourhood. For me, new development (at least large at large scales) is as much about those who will be using the development and for the wider city and metro area. Perhaps 1/3 each. I don't see it's role primarily as a handmaiden to the local surroundings.
So for me, the question is as much "what do the local surroundings do for the new development" as it is the reverse. In that case, being near a pleasant nabe can offer a nice setting for the new residents to explore and enjoy, particularly for those who don't want to be immersed in the heart of downtown but still want to be close, while the existing nabe would gain access to services and transit connections they currently lack. Having new inner city nodes that allow more people to have more choices near the city centre adds value to the city and metro area as a whole. I like seeing busy, dense areas juxtaposed with quiet, leafy areas and having a variety of things to explore in and around the centre city. The highrises are also likelier to have cool views compared to many of those right downtown since they won't be blocked by so many other buildings and some will face the main skyline rather than be in it.
But yes I also hope that it turns out well. I really want something grand and wish it wasn't paired down so much.