The Zaha Hadid design from an article in today's Wall Street Journal
https://si.wsj.net/public/resources/...0320144038.jpg |
This tower is ridiculously epic, though I'm not sure it feels very New York.
But I would be very happy with this design. |
I waver on Hadid. I've liked some of her work but I do not like this design for our city.
|
Follow up: I actually don't mind the tower but there's something about the base that irks me.
|
I would like to see more detail, but I'm cautiously optimistic based on the initial rendering.
The alien curvature of her work is great for neighborhoods with a lot of architectural experimentation (perfect fit in West Chelsea), but can seem a little out of context in neighborhoods with a more established architectural character (like her proposal for 425 Park, which would have drawn too much attention from modern classics like Lever House nearby). With that in mind, I was a bit worried that we would get an overly bold proposal for a tower that totally disregarded the 5th Ave aesthetic. This design might actually be a really nice compromise, though. 5th Ave is the height of glamorous architecture in NYC, whether historic beaux-arts structures (the St. Regis, the Crown Building) or sophisticated modern facades (Valentino or the Rolex Building). This tower is certainly very different than anything else on the street, but it seems to echo that same glamour and semi-royal tone with its high arches and what appears to be gold/copper detailing. I think it has a ton of potential. On a side note, I was completely confused for a moment by the park they rendered on the east side of 5th. |
Quote:
https://cdn-standard.discourse.org/u...a6f2e6a0b1.jpg Credit: https://twitter.com/morninggloria |
It's spectacular
|
Quote:
I knew it would be something like this, covering the base, because of her proposal for 425 Park Avenue. Not bad at all, in fact it could be spectacular. Still trying to decide if it needs a spire or not. Also, not sure why that added that green space to the rendering, but 53W53 should be added to the background in the render for extra punch. Also, you can make out the original building, or at least the dimensions of it, so we need the render from the north/south side to get a full picture. https://therealdeal.com/2017/03/21/k...al-12-billion/ Kushner has even bigger plans for 666 Fifth Avenue — and they total $12B But Anbang's involvement in project is tenuous March 21, 2017 Quote:
A little more from curbed... http://ny.curbed.com/2017/3/21/15016...adid-supertall Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I like the bottom third of it. The sum of all it's parts looks very phallic though. I wish she'd have continued the interesting cladding on the bottom part of the tower up to the top.
|
Quote:
|
It looks like the Salesforce Tower in SF.
|
Reminds me of IM Pei's 1956 Grand Central Station tower proposal.
|
666 5 av
Its beautifull , is diferent , is not an horrible box !!!!!!!!!
|
About a third of the proposal would be condos, but about a third of it would also be retail, a significant development for Fifth Avenue. Nordstrom, if you had only waited.
It's noteworthy that the earliest this thing could likely get built is 2025 - eight years from now. By then, the towers rising now, and even some that have yet to begin will have been built. This would be among the new product, possibly along with a built 80 South Street, maybe Gary Barnett's own Fifth and Eighth Avenue towers. As simply a rebuilding project, it will be an amazing sight to see. http://m7.i.pbase.com/o10/06/102706/...tAaU6Kj.w1.jpg http://m8.i.pbase.com/o10/06/102706/...0PLf6yI.w2.jpg http://m9.i.pbase.com/o10/06/102706/...Jy04h48.w3.JPG http://m5.i.pbase.com/o10/06/102706/...Kd8vLT.r1b.JPG |
Does Zaha's proposal involve renovating/adding to the existing structure?
|
Quote:
Hopefully some of those Vornado or Extell Assemblages will become super talls. |
Masterpiece.
|
Quote:
Quote:
It won't really be a renovation, but a rebuilding, similar in nature to the new 425 Park Avenue. Looking at the lower levels of the tower, I would prefer the transition from the second setback to the tower be similar to the transition from the first setback. But I'm sure they would prefer to have that open deck. The base and first setback of the building would be primarily for the retail. https://static.dezeen.com/uploads/20...s-usa_hero.jpg https://www.dezeen.com/2017/03/23/za...cture-offices/ |
Quote:
Its expensive as it is to buy a tower and demo the whole thing, so I could see many "425 Park like" developments springing up. Where height, due to the benefits of rezoning, is further added to an existing structures and the functionality of an existing tower is changed (hotel, residential, office, ect.). This project is a little more extreme as the structure will be stripped to its steel-core, but in terms of cost, a 425 Park like scenario makes more sense for when there isn't a crazy amount of capital available. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 11:44 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.